Re:Usability expert tears apart Windows 8
by krakensden on Monday November 26, 2012 @12:07AM
(#4830642)
It doesn't make a lot of sense to my why Metro applications need to be fullscreen, especially if lots of applications are supposed to work on a phone form factor too. Stick them in some standard chrome at a standard size, and let them float if the user wants them to float.
What's funny is that moving away from full screen apps was the entire premise of windows in the first place, not to mention the reason for its name. We did full screen apps in the 80's and hated it back then too.
On my laptop for example, I primarily use the desktop features and regular programs. The only time I really touch the metro-styled areas is when I search for a program or file. This sort of a workflow is almost exactly like one would have on Windows 7, and isn't hard to grasp at all.
On a tablet, users would primarily use the metro-styled area (or only use it depending on their version of Windows 8 I guess). I suspect that this wouldn't be too mentally taxing, although I haven't tried it.
The problem then is that this kind of use still basically then divides Windows 8 into two different operating systems, which seems to go against Microsoft's goal of merging the UX on different devices. I don't know if there's a real answer to this - I guess we'll see in the next Windows version as the article states.