That being said, I didn't read the papers in question, and they may have a valid argument.
However, I don't understand how you can encode in 16 per second the evolution of your current experience out of all the possible states your brain may be in and go to.
There is a lot of compression due to expectations, but I still find it hard to believe that it is so low.
Edit: For serial tasks (say, reading, listening to someone speak), the 16-40 bps range makes some sense, but I don't think that visual experience can be reduced that much.
Edit 2: Take, say, music. You can encode the audible note tones on 6-7 bit. You can easily listen 4 notes chords played 4 times per second. We're already in the 100 bps ball park, and we haven't taken timbre and loudness into account.
Furthermore Kupfmuller,Nørretranders are not alone in this regard:
"We can therefore conclude that the maximal information flow of the process of conscious sensory perception is about 40 bits/second -- many orders of magnitude below that taken in by receptors [nerve endings]."
-- Manfred Zimmermann. "Neurophysiology of Sensory Systems" in Robert F. Schmidt ed., Fundamentals of Sensory Physiology (1986) p.116
"... If we do not act in the way we think we do, the reason is partly to do with the bandwidth of consciousness - its ability to transmit information measured in terms of bits per second. [...] The bandwidth of consciousness is around eighteen bits."
--John N Gray (2002) [3][4]
First prize would be evidence for a refutation of the 'consciousness operates at a low information rate' hypothesis, as opposed to conjecture or speculation.
[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tor_N%C3%B8rretranders
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karl_K%C3%BCpfm%C3%BCller
[2] http://www.amazon.com/Fundamentals-Sensory-Physiology-Spring...
[3] http://www.amazon.com/Straw-Dogs-Thoughts-Humans-Animals/dp/...
[4] http://books.google.com/books?id=k5PkZXJEQqoC&lpg=PA45&#...