News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In UK, Twitter, Facebook rants land some in jail by anigbrowl on Sunday November 25, 2012 @03:31AM (#4827686)
to use violence to keep your fellow citizens or subjects from saying original but forbidden things.

You're rather begging the question there. What constitutes originality - is it meant to be a proxy for innovative? What if I say something obnoxious but unoriginal, such as advocating genocide or harm of some group or other who have been systematically discriminated against in the past?

Re:In UK, Twitter, Facebook rants land some in jail by batgaijin on Sunday November 25, 2012 @04:40AM (#4827772)
well that's why in good old America we've discovered how to innovate in the area of making free speech useless.

when you have a small but fervent religious population that takes any criticism as 'an attack on free speech' it marginalizes whatever the actual issue may be; when any issue can be trumped up to a philosophical issue instead of a pragmatic and factual one.

Re:In UK, Twitter, Facebook rants land some in jail by anigbrowl on Sunday November 25, 2012 @09:25PM (#4830104)
This is exactly my issue. It's not acceptable to say you want to infringe upon speech, but it's perfectly OK to advocate torture, death, imprisonment or suchlike for people you don't like. Of course, such actions are also restrictive of speech in two ways - directly, since being dead or incommunicado is an insurmountable barrier to expression, and indirectly, since members of the group in question are intimidated from speaking up - but since the deleterious effects on free speech are incidental to the proposed harm, constitutional modesty is preserved.
Re:In UK, Twitter, Facebook rants land some in jail by CamperBob2 on Sunday November 25, 2012 @02:48PM (#4829051)
You're rather begging the question there. What constitutes originality - is it meant to be a proxy for innovative?

It's almost certain that someone would have tried to derail my point by citing the Skylarov case and other instances where we've sold free speech down the river in the name of preserving someone's business model. I used the qualifier "original" to avoid debates about the conflict between free speech and IP rights. It was sort of cowardly for me to do that, but there are only so many hours in the day.

What if I say something obnoxious but unoriginal, such as advocating genocide or harm of some group or other who have been systematically discriminated against in the past?

I think we have a pretty good standard in place now, which is that your words have to carry a more-or-less direct threat to a specific party in order to lose their First Amendment protection. Apart from that, and apart from cases where your speech constitutes someone else's IP or is the product of a crime such as espionage or child pornography, it's rare that the US government will be able to censor you. (Although they can certainly try.)

It's my position that no one can point to any lasting, demonstrable harm caused by the exercise of First Amendment rights. Even the much-loathed Citizens United decision turned out to be a nonissue in the last election. First Amendment libertarians say that the antidote to bad speech is more speech. We're right, and the countries that believe otherwise are wrong. If that's "arrogance," well, so be it.