News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In UK, Twitter, Facebook rants land some in jail by jacquesm on Sunday November 25, 2012 @02:34AM (#4827584)
> Women should have the right to vote. The color of your skin shouldn't decide your destiny in life. Slavery did need to end.

Plenty of countries were ahead on all three of those regardless of the right to 'free speech'.

There are lots of good things about the United States, there are lots of bad things too. Free Speech is good, but it did not automatically lead to the abolishment of slavery, a lack of discrimination and the women vote. It definitely helped but the courage of those standing up for their rights was orders of magnitude more important. It also does not translate into being able to say whatever you want.

And in spite of free speech the United States still has a long way to go when it comes to citizens rights, due process, cross border criminality and last but not least the rights of LGBT people.

The United States is not at the pinnacle of civilization yet and there are tons of countries that rank higher on various parameters than the United States does.

Re:In UK, Twitter, Facebook rants land some in jail by csense on Sunday November 25, 2012 @03:24AM (#4827659)
> it did not automatically lead to the abolishment of slavery, a lack of discrimination and the women vote

That's not the point. The point is that, in 100 years, some of the things that you, me and most of our friends think today might turn out to have been terrible, shortsighted, bigoted groupthink mistakes that resulted in the oppression of millions of people.

We aren't doing it on purpose, of course. We try to be as vigilant as we can about that sort of error by constantly considering different ideas and questioning our own assumptions, prejudices, and cultural habits.

It's hard to do that if it's illegal to talk about different ideas, or say that we might be headed in the wrong direction.

And if it turns out that, despite our best efforts, we can't see the truth which will eventually emerge -- then we shouldn't compound the evils caused by our wrongheaded beliefs by using the power of the state to silence our critics.

Re:In UK, Twitter, Facebook rants land some in jail by jacquesm on Sunday November 25, 2012 @05:17AM (#4827816)
> That's not the point.

Well, then maybe you should not have used those as examples to bolster your argument. As it is they don't hold water.

> The point is that, in 100 years, some of the things that you, me and most of our friends think today might turn out to have been terrible, shortsighted, bigoted groupthink mistakes that resulted in the oppression of millions of people.

So, please name some examples where free speech in the United States right now gives it the moral high ground on some subject, higher ground than that reached in countries without free speech by your definition, but otherwise functional democracies (i.e. a very large number of countries).

> We aren't doing it on purpose, of course.

Right now, in your country there are lots of groups actively promoting hatred behind the fig-leaf of free speech, and there are a lot of issues that are not being resolved with people purposely obstructing others in spite of free speech. The correlation between 'free speech' meaningful progress on any of these fronts is not visible to me as an outsider.

> It's hard to do that if it's illegal to talk about different ideas, or say that we might be headed in the wrong direction.

There are a large number of countries that do not have American style 'free speech' where talking about different ideas or saying that you're headed in the wrong direction is not illegal.

> And if it turns out that, despite our best efforts, we can't see the truth which will eventually emerge -- then we shouldn't compound the evils caused by our wrongheaded beliefs by using the power of the state to silence our critics.

There are more options than Iran, North Korea and The United States. Many of those options are perfectly workable and produce societies that are morally speaking the equivalent or the superior of the United States.

Feel free to lecture the rest of us on how well Free Speech works when you have your house in order, until then it is just one more factor in a very large number of factors. It is a positive factor, but when you fail on so many other fronts that its effect fades into insignificance you might as well not have it.

Re:In UK, Twitter, Facebook rants land some in jail by CamperBob2 on Sunday November 25, 2012 @03:29PM (#4829179)
Feel free to lecture the rest of us on how well Free Speech works when you have your house in order

I don't think any country including the US is exempt from criticism -- very strong criticism, at that -- on a variety of fronts. Several people here have tried to derail the discussion into areas such as slavery, women's suffrage, the Second Amendment, torture, or whatever, but those are all offtopic for the (sub)thread. Our house is not "in order," and neither is yours or anyone else's, so what's the point in dragging out a laundry list of unrelated accusations?

Re:In UK, Twitter, Facebook rants land some in jail by csense on Sunday November 25, 2012 @03:45AM (#4827704)
My other comment is the most important thing I have to say to this, but in regard to your other points:

> There are lots of good things about the United States, there are lots of bad things too...in spite of free speech the United States still has a long way to go when it comes to...The United States is not at the pinnacle of civilization yet...

I never said that improvement was impossible or the USA was number one in every category of freedom.

My point was that we Americans tend to assume the UK is like us, due to our common language, shared history, superpower status, democratic government, etc. -- so it's a bit of a shock to realize that things which would be perfectly legal free speech here are illegal in the UK.

> [Free speech] also does not translate into being able to say whatever you want.

I never said it did. In the US, it's illegal to say things that will cause a panic or incite violence. Obscenity is a special category with a long history of regulation, which has been rolled back considerably in the last fifty years or so. Individuals have some degree of privacy with regard to publication of photos or details of their lives, which is less for politicians or other public figures. Lies which harm someone's reputation can result in a successful lawsuit. Commercial advertising has to be truthful. Free speech protections only apply to government actions; private individuals or organizations can set their own rules for spaces they own. (Just read an HN post about Apple's prudishness with respect to app content a little while ago [1].) Just being able to legally say something doesn't mean you should; saying controversial things may make people and businesses shy away from associating with you. It may be hard to find friends or employment if you make a habit of expressing highly unpopular or distasteful opinions.

Personally, I feel free to cut loose with this ID. I say what I want -- usually what I actually believe, but sometimes I play devil's advocate or seek out controversy. I think HN can be just a hair on the insular side sometimes, getting itself into one big groupthink because most of us are rather similar in a lot of ways; I try to push others out of their comfort zone when I think it'll be good for them, and for HN and society as a whole. I suppose you can think of me as a friendly troll.

But I'm well aware of the risks of free speech. Other than IP address, there's absolutely nothing about this ID which correlates with my real identity or my identity in other places online. I don't express myself strongly on controversial topics like politics or religion in real life, unless I'm with friends who I know well and who are intellectually strong enough to agree to disagree -- something even very bright people sometimes are not.

[1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4825235