Of course, its difficult comparing suicide rates in different countries, and other factors may be at play, but this just goes to show that suicides are not a good metric to make this otherwise perfectly valid point (when more teenagers kill themselves here than in foxconn plants, the argument becomes more difficult that everyone is killing themselves because things are so terrible). Suicide itself is an incredibly complex topic that should probably not be trivialized. This is of course not to say conditions there are in any way good, they're not. I just think its better to rely on the other much more ample and obvious evidence.
1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teenage_suicide_in_the_United_S...
Not necessarily. The #10 cause for the general population may be deadlier than the #1 cause for 15-24 year olds. That Here are some made up numbers:
15-24 year olds: 0.1% deaths/year, of which 10% due to suicide
general population: 1% deaths per year, of which 5% due to suicide
That would have 0.01% of all 15-24 commit suicide each year, but 0.05% of the general population.As I said, I made up the numbers. However, I do not think they are completely out of range. 1% deaths in a stable population gives a life expectancy of 100 years, but the US population is growing and hence relatively young. Also, looking at http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr60/nvsr60_03.pdf, Figure 3, I think 1% is a reasonable guess at that figure.
The x% due to suicide numbers likely are exaggerations (a Zipf curve will have trouble getting to 5% in rank 10)
http://www.wired.com/magazine/2011/02/ff_joelinchina/
I think US college students is a socioeconomically appropriate group to compare with.
So suicide rate can't be used as a proxy for measuring employee conditions.
I was going to suggest that the lower rate could be due to having more female workers, since far more men then women commit suicide BUT it turns out that in China this is not the case (in US studies they measure that women try a lot but don't succeed at the same rate - cause of that is contentious argument - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_and_suicide).
To answer main thread, the article does include a bunch of bollocks (my favorite bit is where they try to shock us with the half-life of Uranium), but the core of the article seems to be probably valid.
Aside: why is it so common that eco-articles (or eco-movies) ruin their core theme by adding outrageous bollocks?
Except everyone mentions the Foxconn Suicides as a major problem. Giving actual numbers is a way to remedy that specific bit of untruth.
> my favorite bit is where they try to shock us with the half-life of Uranium
For the people who don't know: Long half-life means lower radiation over any given period. The really hot stuff, the stuff that throws off a lot of radiation per second, doesn't last long precisely because it's throwing away so much energy to get to a more stable state. Isotopes that stick around longer do so because they're more stable, and so have less energy to throw away every second.
I see this often cited when talking about suicides at Foxconn but comparing suicides at a company to the general population is not that useful. The population of Foxconn workers are young(typical age reported to be 18) and 100% employed. That's not a group of people you want to compare to a span-all-socioeconomic-classes general population.