Re:I Don't Want To Be Part of Your Ecosystem
by zmmmmm on Friday November 23, 2012 @05:26PM
(#4823879)
Android is an interesting example. Google did use a linux kernel but threw out everything GPL they possibly could above that, to the point of writing their own libc. So I wouldn't really call it an example of GPL winning. It's equally an example of how it was necessary to throw away piles of code because it was GPL's and couldn't be used in commercially compatible way.
Re:I Don't Want To Be Part of Your Ecosystem
by rhizome on Saturday November 24, 2012 @12:34AM
(#4824641)
The GPL was never intended to eliminate NIH Syndrome.
Re:I Don't Want To Be Part of Your Ecosystem
by millstone on Friday November 23, 2012 @03:39PM
(#4823588)
Android could have based itself on a BSD, or even xnu, and done just fine.
Re:I Don't Want To Be Part of Your Ecosystem
by Evbn on Friday November 23, 2012 @11:36AM
(#4822732)
Internet killed GPL. AGPL tried to win the Inernet, and the corporations dodged it.
There are some interesting network effects at work here. Th e more GPL'd software there is out there the bigger the chunk you have to write yourself (or pay someone to write) would have to be if you want to forego it.
Hence Linksys and Android.
Those would have never gotten as far as they did without the GPL's software underneath their externally visible features as a foundation to build on.
Linux on the desktop may never happen, but linux in your pocket is pretty much a foregone conclusion at this point.