News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The big data disaster by nostrademons on Thursday November 22, 2012 @01:14PM (#4819549)
The point of discounts, coupons, etc. isn't to get you to buy, it's to build very comprehensive data on the demand elasticity curves of each good they sell.

If you've taken an introductory microeconomics course, you'll remember that almost all the models of a "rational" firm involve maximizing profit by picking a price point where people still buy yet will pay a maximum price per unit. How firms determine that demand curve is left as an exercise - it's assumed that firms who get it right will survive while firms that don't will go out of business, leaving only firms who get it right. This is cold comfort if you're a business owner and want your firm to get it right.

So what do the big retailers do? They A/B test. They divide customers into two groups (say, those who have a Safeway card and those who don't) and offer a different price to each. Then they measure how much of each good people will buy at each price, and presumably do some statistical corrections for demographics, the "sale" effect (where people buy whatever's on sale regardless of price), folks who won't use coupons no matter how cheap, etc. They end the sale, and then pick a different price next month. Over time, they build up extensive data about just how high they can raise their prices before people stop buying entirely.

So when you ignore the discount, that's Mission Fucking Accomplished for the store. It's telling them that the discount doesn't matter, and you'll buy regardless, and so they should try raising the price instead. They don't care about the sale, they care about the data, so that they can make more money from all their other customers.

Re:The big data disaster by haddr on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:23PM (#4819738)
Yeah, probably they do everything you say. but then again: if they rise prices then you would go to the next supermarket instead.
Re:The big data disaster by dreamdu5t on Thursday November 22, 2012 @01:58PM (#4819689)
Honest, you just kind of blew my mind. I find it hard to believe they actually do that though?
Re:The big data disaster by nostrademons on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:12PM (#4819719)
I've never worked at a brick & mortar retailer, so I can't know for sure. I know for sure that online retailers do this - a few have been caught showing different prices to different customers, or to the same customer in different browsers. I'd be very surprised if Walmart/Target/Safeway/CVS/etc. don't - what else is the point of the "rewards card" if not to gather detailed data? Why do they seemingly have a different "everyday low price" every month?
Re:The big data disaster by rohamg on Friday November 23, 2012 @04:05AM (#4821472)
While I think you're right re:data (got my up vote for that!), Safeway club card is a bad example- 1) it's basket-wide and 2) almost everyone uses it. SW CC is good old fashioned price discrimination, which is designed to capture producer surplus from customers whose willingness to pay is greater than the market price. Many other examples incl. airline tickets: the extra charge for first or for a flexible ticket isn't because it costs that much to keep your spot flexible in their model, it's simply to price discriminate and be able to charge as high as the market will pay. Nothing wrong with it, but the key difference is that the sale itself does matter.