News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Windows Store and the GPL by stcredzero on Thursday November 22, 2012 @12:45PM (#4819460)
Is there any business reason why the Apple App Store couldn't have comparable terms?
Re:Windows Store and the GPL by saurik on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:41PM (#4819783)
Apple does a lot of things that probably don't have sound business reasons behind them in the name of control (which, in turn, they often claim is a business reason: I have yet to see any good evidence of this, however, only correlation that "Apple is successful" and "Apple is controlling", but no attempt to control for "Apple actually builds good things occasionally, and their competition is often incompetent in their attempts to build the same things, at least for the high-end market that scores you a lot of the $-points that people using attempt to score 'successful' with").

In this case, iOS is the one platform (well, technically Android could, and there is probably at least a couple handset manufacturers who decided to do this, but I can't come up with any off the top of my head) that requires you to pay Apple a subscription fee (the amount being unimportant: the key being that it allows them to better limit and control access, gives them options on how to track people or ban them) even if all you want to do is compile a normal application (not the fancy stuff we jailbreak for, but a regular-old boring "app") and load it on to you own device.

In contrast, Microsoft and Google only do this if you want to distribute your software using their marketplaces: you can, for free, "side-load" applications, with at most having to turn off some protection switch under Settings. (In the case of Microsoft, you still need an account, but as someone else pointed out it seems to be free; personally I think that actually is already out of scope for a GPL application, at least under a license like GPLv3 if not GPLv2; I am probably in the minority opinion on this: though, I'd find the FSF's opinion interesting.) Apple probably believes there is a business reason for this.

Re:Windows Store and the GPL by rodgerd on Thursday November 22, 2012 @03:51PM (#4819944)
Richard Stallman tells a story (or did when I saw him give a lecture a decade or so ago) about Steve Jobs approaching him to do a deal on allowing NeXT to keep the GCC Objective C front end closed; rms explained that wasn't going to happen, and NeXT would have to GPL it.

I wouldn't be surprised if Apple's enthusiasm for LLVM and distaste for GPL code stems from that incident.

Re:Windows Store and the GPL by Someone on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:20PM (#4820222)
For the history buffs:

  - https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups=#!searchin/gnu.gcc/NeXT$20and$20copyleft

  - https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups=#!searchin/gnu.gcc/Objective-C$20front$20end$20for$20GCC$20from$20NeXT
I do not see Steve mentioned anywhere (http://ebb.org/bkuhn/talks/OSCON-2011/compliance.html makes that link, but IMO lacks argumentation).

It is hard to tell, but it seems that there were a few months where a pure preprocessor was (getting?) integrated into gcc, where the idea was to ship gcc sources with a NeXT licensed library to users, and have those users do the linking step, thus preventing NeXT from breaking the GPL. One could argue that this was one of the things that, eventually, led to the library exception to the GPL (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU_General_Public_License#Vers...)