News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI eats the world (Spring 26) [pdf] by aurareturn on Monday May 18, 2026 @01:48PM (#48182917)
In slide 22, it compares LLM labs (OpenAI/Anthropic) to mobile data telecoms (AT&T, Verizon, TMobile) in 2010s. The difference is that mobile telecoms follow a standard (3G, 4G LTE, 5G) and there is little to no differentiation. It's virtually the same no matter which company you choose or which country you travel to.

A better comparison is actually AWS/Azure/Google Cloud/NeoClouds to AT&T and Verizon. The data centers follow a standard (CUDA/PyTorch/etc.) while OpenAI and Anthropic are becoming more like iOS and Android. Both the clouds and telecoms had to spend a ton of capex to build out infrastructure first.

Because of what I think is a poor comparison, the the next few slides make the wrong conclusions. For example, it thinks that models will be a commodity like 5G data. I disagree. I think frontier models are a classic duopoly/monopoly scenario. The smarter the model, the more it gets used, the more revenue it generates, the more compute the company can buy, the smarter the next model and so on. It's a flywheel effect. This is similar to advanced chip nodes like TSMC where your current node has to make enough money to pay for the next node. TSMC owns something like 95%+ of all of the most advanced node market. Back in the 80s and 90s, you had dozens of chip fab companies. Today, there are only 3. There should only be 1 but national security saved Intel and Samsung fabs.

There is evidence that the Chinese models are falling further behind, not gaining. Consolidation will likely happen soon because many unprofitable open source labs will have to merge and focus on revenue generation.

Re:AI eats the world (Spring 26) [pdf] by benedictevans on Monday May 18, 2026 @02:45PM (#48183781)
I've made the semi comparison myself, but the amount of capital required to build a SOTA model today is clearly nowhere near enough to lead to a monopoly.

I'm aware that telecoms networks are standardised (I was once a telecoms analyst), but that isn't a precondition for a commodity.

Re:AI eats the world (Spring 26) [pdf] by aurareturn on Monday May 18, 2026 @02:54PM (#48183933)
Just like how starting a chip fab was relatively easy back in the 80s and 90s. There were dozens of chip fab companies in the 80s.

It turns out that fabs follow Rock's Law which is that the capital cost to build a new fab doubles every 4 years. This means it will quickly get rid of the less competitive players. This is not dissimilar to the LLM scaling laws where you need a magnitude more compute to get unlock a new tier of intelligence.

Today, Anthropic and OpenAI are clearly in the lead for models and then there is everyone else. Google is a close 3rd. No one else is challenging them anymore in SOTA models. Some models might beat them in one or two benchmarks but none can compete overall. I expect this gap to grow bigger as models cost more and more to train.

Re:AI eats the world (Spring 26) [pdf] by benedictevans on Monday May 18, 2026 @04:12PM (#48184920)
Yes, I wrote about Rock’s Law too, but we don’t know that this is how these models will develop
Re:AI eats the world (Spring 26) [pdf] by aurareturn on Monday May 18, 2026 @11:06PM (#48188731)
Evidence point to the same type of scaling law.
Re:AI eats the world (Spring 26) [pdf] by menaerus on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:11AM (#48191052)
You lay out some good arguments but I agree with both: the models relative to few years back really did become the commodity because today you could take the non-frontier model, maybe self-host it or pay the much less price per M tokens to get the performance of a ~2-year old frontier model. At the same time I do think that we are getting into the monopoly/duopoly/tripoly with the frontier models for all the reasons you already mentioned, and this scares me a little bit.
Re:AI eats the world (Spring 26) [pdf] by aurareturn on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:43AM (#48191251)
Lower intelligence LLMs can be a commodity, yes. But these won't make much money, if at all. At the end of the day, it costs the same to inference a 1T frontier model and a 1T free model.

OpenAI and Anthropic don't compete in the LLM commodity market. Hence, I had a problem with slide 22.

Re:AI eats the world (Spring 26) [pdf] by fittingopposite on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @11:41AM (#48194808)
How about the externalized intelligence around the model weights (skills, tools, harness, memory etc)? If the model weights are sufficiently intelligent, the focus might move to the external layers.
Re:AI eats the world (Spring 26) [pdf] by svnt on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @12:44PM (#48195764)
I agree with much of what you’ve written but think you are missing the correct alignment of the mobile data timeline — mobile data had standards because it was forced to. It was forced to early because it was not a fundamental innovation, telecom itself was the fundamental innovation, mobile was a constraint relaxation. Intelligence might be forced to have standards as well, we will see what form the regulations take when prices reflect costs and healthy margins and become existential threats for many businesses.
Re:AI eats the world (Spring 26) [pdf] by aurareturn on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @02:17PM (#48197104)
Intelligence can’t be standardized.

The reason mobile data had to standardize is because it’s a network and a network must have protocols. It’s useless without them.

Re:AI eats the world (Spring 26) [pdf] by svnt on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:58PM (#48200238)
I agree with that as a premise, but again it seems to me you are selectively jumping way into the end game. There were early networks that did not standardize, and these nonstandard networks had advantages, and some of those advantages were sacrificed in market-driven standardization.

Intelligence must have interfaces, and those can be standardized. Businesses will try to remain provider agnostic, which will also drive standardization via standard sales and marketing methods.

Separately, we are doing our best to standardize performances on benchmarks.

I don’t disagree that right now transport of standardized mobile data vs emulation of human intelligence is qualitatively different, but perhaps primarily because it is early in development, and our vantage point this time is relatively from within the network, instead of outside it.

Re:AI eats the world (Spring 26) [pdf] by danny_codes on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @02:06AM (#48203695)
I doubt it. Compute costs tend to crater over time, and LLMs will almost certainly plateau. So the opposite is almost certainly the case: over time, it becomes cheaper to train.
Re:AI eats the world (Spring 26) [pdf] by aurareturn on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @04:55AM (#48204912)
By that time, there would be a clear monopoly or duopoly that controls the revenue, distribution, and compute.
Re:AI eats the world (Spring 26) [pdf] by danny_codes on Friday May 22, 2026 @12:26AM (#48231921)
Possible, but only if there’s regulatory capture. Which will be difficult since any country could produce a SOTA model that everyone can use for free
Re:AI eats the world (Spring 26) [pdf] by musebox35 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @06:11AM (#48191434)
Most of your analysis I can easily relate to except “There is evidence that the Chinese models are falling further behind, not gaining.” Where is that evidence? Deepseekv4 claims to be trailing front runners by six months. I read people agreeing with this. I watched Eric Schmidt to recently make similar comments. Is he just scaremongering? Why do you claim they are falling behind?
Re:AI eats the world (Spring 26) [pdf] by aurareturn on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @09:21AM (#48192996)
A few evidence I pieced together:

1. Ex-ByteDance Engineer said so recently: https://www.businessinsider.com/ex-bytedance-engineer-says-c...

2. A benchmark concludes so: https://www.nist.gov/news-events/news/2026/05/caisi-evaluati...

3. Generally, people say Chinese models bench better than they perform

I think it seems to make sense given that China does not have access to Blackwell while in the past, they at least had access to gimped H200s.