I agree for certain fields such as your example but until recently software engineers were in disproportional demand and that has changed pretty dramatically in less time than one would need to get a degree in the field.
Edit: And the example of people working in construction: I know a few. Their companies are booked out for the next 2 years. They, however have shitty pay and disproportionately many work-caused health problems. The owners of those companies are having a good time though.
A 24 year old friend works construction, building and restoring facades and such. Makes 70-80k Euros/year with his own schwarzgeld overtime outside of work. It's on par with a senior SW engineer with 10YOE here. Hard work indeed, but not poorly paid.
It's only poorly paid for unskilled positions in construction that are basically human carrying robots who haven't yet been automated.
There is no such thing as a shortage in labor markets. There is just people not willing to pay the correct price.
I once met this foreign guy in Germany who lived a life bouncing between seasonal part time work and unemployment and laughed at me when he heard I was working and how much I was making. He said, "why don't you go on welfare and have kids instead? The government pays your rent and bills and no more stress from work."
IMHO if you want to restore balance in the jobs market, then you need to cut welfare, employment taxes and government bureaucracy. As long as government burdens both the employee and employer with crazy taxes and red tape, and then redistributes those taxes poorly via corruption, populism and incompetence, then of course the market will always be distorted and fucked and there will always be a simultaneous shortage and an oversupply, never a balance.
I really don't know much about it, I'd have assumed it follows a similar model to the Swedish one: you can be on benefits while searching for a job, there's even a government agency tasked with finding positions you might qualify, you are required to apply to X jobs a month, and if you get offered a job you need to take it or you will get benefits cut.
Of course, there are ways to prolong it but it's definitely not enough to create major distortions, you will eventually run the clock out on the unemployment payments. Also to have decent unemployment you need to have contributed to an unemployment fund, there's a national one available to all citizens which doesn't pay much, otherwise you need to have funded the one provided by your union.
As always, it depends on your definition and situation. If you're a highly skilled, ambitious worker, with a desire for a high standard of living, then no.
If you're unskilled and unscrupulous and willing to game the system every step of the way(like some people I met), then being on welfare definitely pays better than doing unskilled labor, with the advantage you don't come home every day smelly and tired having to wake up early the next day for a long commute to go through this grind every day.
>you will eventually run the clock out on the unemployment payments.
You can prolong this indefinitely by destroying your mind and body with drugs and alcohol so you can go on disability benefits, and not worry about job interviews ever again, because nobody will hire you.
>Of course, there are ways to prolong it but it's definitely not enough to create major distortions
Yeah, NO, it definitely does major distortions. If welfare turns from a temporary safety net only used by a few and paid by many, to a system now many rely on long term and paid only by a few, then it ends up distorting everything: the tax system, the labor market, the rental market, government spending and debt, etc. all of which negatively affect a nation's economic competitiveness.
My point was entirely focused on the Swedish model which doesn't create major distortions due to how it works, you cannot be on welfare for an undetermined amount of time unless you are disabled.
For your points, I believe we need real hard data, I cannot determine if what you say about Germany is actually true without looking at it. How many people in Germany are living only on welfare for long periods (at least 12 months, what proportion stays for 24+ months)? What is the proportion between people temporarily on welfare vs long-term ones (excluding disabilities that remove someone from the labour pool)? What percentage of Germany's budget go to service welfare costs for the issue you brought up (people living on welfare instead of working)?
I'm asking for hard data because it smells very much like the "welfare queens" trope used in the USA by Reagan which was absolute bullshit.
Education and everything else related for the youth is free(taxpayer funded and government provided) in Europe. Whose responsibility is it to make ends meet other than your own? If you end up doing doordash after being provided all those generous opportunities in your youth, maybe some self reflection is needed.
Should we keep taxing small business entrepreneurs and higher earners more, to subsidize the lower earners so adults can sit at home instead of doing doordash, while having food delivery service jobs be done by a parallel society comprised of desperate migrants and refugees, which need to be brought it endlessly to keep this ponzi scheme going, because the locals feel like it's below them. Is this better for Europe?
we don't live in an age where we must struggle continously...
if there's 1000 positions but 3000 people looking for jobs, do you suggest 2000 people are put out there to figure it out themselves?
hopefully you get my idea here.
Though I really doubt your anecdotes, I lived in Berlin for years as a non-German speaker, you have a lot of native speakers all around, you often do not notice when you’re not integrated but once you start following native Germans they bring you to groups and places where the language is way more common.
Last time I was in Berlin, I had to pretend to be Finnish to avoid speaking English and practice my German. That guy was a native German speaker. But I came across plenty of people who did not speak good German but were local residents. So I don't disbelieve her. I spent time in Dresden years ago, and it was easy for me to find Germans to speak with (nowadays, I think that may be different as youngsters are all drilled in American English.) Sächsisch is a somewhat strange accent, but at least it is a native dialect. I already know someone else's broken German, I'm not trying to learn their broken German.
I think the time to be in Berlin was the eighties and nineties. Even 1980s era East Berlin appears to have had some appeal (according to East Germans I've interacted with, despite issues with the Stasi.) Outside of the touristy parts, the modern suburbs are fast evolving into just another global city with non-descript glass and steel cylinders filled with junk food outlets and Air BnB. (Not that East German era architecture is that distinctive either.)
Another trick I've learnt sometimes is to drop into a broad Scottish accent so they cannot understand what I am saying in English. But my German is extremely rusty nowadays.
Germans often switch to English when they hear an accent or hesitation
Is Germany not enough diverse for you?
> As of 2024, around 17.4 million people living in Germany, or 20.9% of the population, are first-generation immigrants, while the population with a migrant background in the wider sense stood at approximately 25.2 million, accounting for 30.2% of the total population of 83.5 million
Thats a very misleading statistic
It's an anecdotal evidence, but while looking for a job I liked looking up employees on linkedin, then looking up the leadership on company's website. First one would always be much more diverse than the second one
My grandparents had many brothers and sisters each and life was harder back then, but it was easier to raise a large family than today. What changed? Taxes, with direct and indirect effects.
Contraception. Children weren't optional back then, they just happened naturally.
Most historians who work as historians dont work in archeological sites, so I dont see how that part is relevant.
> In areas like constructions and handymen there is a serious shortage, if not a crisis, in the entire Western Europe. There are jobs, but not the ones most people want.
Are salaries going up?
> it is hard work and most people don't want it (diversity and equality does not work in such jobs, never did)
Like, you mean, immigrants wont be accepted if they apply? Cause wherever I was, these low level jobs were exactly the jobs where immigrants went first - they would hire literally almost anyone as they were not picky on language knowledge, cultural knowledge or even skills. All they asked for was time and ability to accept low salary with not too great conditions.
But, if they wont accept immigrants on principle, the inability to find workers is their own problem. Native Germans has obviously more options.
Nobody wants to talk about the cause because it's not politically correct: Government paying people enough to avoid doing work they don't like, thereby distorting the labor market.
> If "well-qualified people" means fresh graduates in domains with low demand, then the qualification does not matter.
It matters because generations of young people have been gaslit by the government and by society that a degree from a prestigious government accredited university is a meal ticket.
>areas like constructions and handymen there is a serious shortage, if not a crisis, in the entire Western Europe.
You think Eastern Europe is spared? Who do you think works on construction sites in Western Europe, if not Eastern Europeans.
>it is hard work and most people don't want it
Cut all welfare and government handouts, cut taxes on labor and on employment.
Eastern Europe has the former, and as for the latter entrepreneurs in the industry just don't pay their taxes - ask me how I know.
There's still a shortage.
Yeah but for completely different reasons.
Highly skilled workers from Eastern Europe go to US, London, Zurich to make big money there better than back home, and low-skilled workers from Eastern Europe go to Germany for the generous welfare and child benefits better than back home.
I'm originally from Eastern Europe too. Countries like Poland, Czechia, Slovakia and the Baltics managed to avoid this outcome, but Hungary and those in the Balkans are kind of stuck in this downward spiral they can't get out of. They've already lost of lot of workers, both skilled and unskilled to the west, and local birth rates are shit and EU funding won't last forever.
Any kind of economic miracle recovery similar to Poland seems out of the question now. Once the war in Ukraine ends, most EU funds will go there instead of the balkans so if they haven't built a strong economy by the time Ukraine enters the EU, they're truly fucked. Similar how East Germany was fucked after Poland entered the EU.
Strangely the wages don’t rise as one would expect.
And companies are picky, they want a perfect fit for their position including the work processes and programs.
Delusional.
Yes, companies are picky, but it is slowly changing. They cannot afford to be picky anymore, but change takes time.
The example at the beginning seems to be a now classic "I have a degree in an area where supply greatly exceeds demand". There is demand, there is supply, but there is a misalignment of qualifications and interests. If "well-qualified people" means fresh graduates in domains with low demand, then the qualification does not matter. In areas like constructions and handymen there is a serious shortage, if not a crisis, in the entire Western Europe. There are jobs, but not the ones most people want.
Too many people go to universities for a degree without checking if there is demand for these degree. Many that I know go to universities just to have a degree, they don't even care what is the domain. I have a childhood friend that is regularly unemployed, he is a historian, but he does not like working in archeological sites and there is not enough need for historians. At the same time we cannot find enough people for construction works, it is hard work and most people don't want it (diversity and equality does not work in such jobs, never did).