News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by paulsutter on Thursday November 22, 2012 @01:07AM (#4817715)
This article is pure crybaby bullshit PR about a nonexistent problem. Does anyone care about DDG anyway? They're trying to solve a completely imaginary problem, and they haven't got a hope in hell of creating a viable search engine as that costs billions of dollars.

Why is this article even on HN?

Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by javajosh on Thursday November 22, 2012 @01:34AM (#4817762)
Why is your comment the #1 comment? I mean, I count 3, count them, 3 unsubstantiated claims:

1. Does anyone care about DDG anyway? I think it's safe to say, yes, there are some who do. I for one.

2. The problem DDG is solving is imaginary. Oh really? What precisely is that problem? Is it search itself that you're referring to, or the prospect of going up against Google? If the former, then you are delusional, and if the latter, there is nothing wrong with attempting to disrupt a monopoly.

3. A search engine costs billions of dollars. Actually, no. There is no rule of computer science that says that. If someone discovers a new, cheaper way to do search then cool!

In answer to your final question, perhaps the reason this article is on HN is to inspire comments like yours, which are wrong, and then comments like mine, which correct comments like yours.

Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by paulsutter on Thursday November 22, 2012 @08:09AM (#4818614)
The privacy problem is imaginary because (a) only a puny fraction of users care, and (b) thanks to the "patriot" act, our ISPs are storing our search history anyway.

I have worked on search (see my background), and doing search well is massively difficult. The problem has deep necessary complexity, and Google has invested thousands of PhD years against that already. If Google were incompetent, maybe I could see it. But they're damned smart and their product is extremely good.

Data is also a problem - Microsoft has been collecting all your google searches since IE8, and can probably just clone Google's search results for the top few million queries. But even given that, Bing is a massive undertaking.

Since nobody uses DDG, Google can't be expected to make them a default search choice in Chrome. Accusing Google of some malfeasance is just childish and silly.

Finally, the name DDG is atrocious. Really bad in more ways than I have time to list.

Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by mistercow on Thursday November 22, 2012 @09:16AM (#4818796)
>thanks to the "patriot" act, our ISPs are storing our search history anyway.

I think you're thinking of PCIPA (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protecting_Children_from_Intern... ), which would do that, but is still a long way from becoming law. I am fairly sure that the USA PATRIOT Act does not contain any such provision.

Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by paulsutter on Thursday November 22, 2012 @10:29AM (#4819022)
From the EFF, regarding the "Patriot" act:

"At the very least, this change means that the government can use a pen-trap to see the email addresses of people youre sending email to and the addresses of people who send email to you, along with the timestamp and size in bytes of each email. The FBI can monitor the IP addresses of all the computers you interact with over the Internet, or capture the IP addresses of every person visiting a particular website. Under the vaguely written statute, it may even be able to capture the URL of every web page that you read, although the FBI refuses to confirm or deny whether it has done so."

Sure, I should have inserted the word [can], but it hardly changes the point. Given the direction laws have taken since 9/11, you would be foolish to rely on your search activity remaining anonymous.

http://w2.eff.org/patriot/sunset/214.php

Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by mistercow on Thursday November 22, 2012 @10:35AM (#4819037)
While awful, that is not in any way the same thing as ISPs storing our search history. It means that the FBI can monitor internet usage on an individual basis, not that the ISPs are tracking and storing everybody's internet usage.
Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by ok_craig on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:17AM (#4817863)
I think the imaginary problem he meant was searching without being "tracked." The vast majority of users simply don't care. The ones who do can get around it.
Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by greglindahl on Thursday November 22, 2012 @01:39AM (#4817780)
Blekko has a 4 billion page crawl and index, and we've only raised $55 million so far.
Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by Surio on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:24AM (#4817880)
Greg, I love the work you guys have put on Blekko so far (and keep putting). Thanks. Keep it up!
Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by yegg on Thursday November 22, 2012 @01:54AM (#4817812)
Hi, this is Gabriel Weinberg, the guy mentioned in the article.

The main issue I have is with duck.com. A lot of people remember that we are a search engine "duck something" and so naturally try duck.com. As a result, there is a lot of confusion, e.g.:

"I was telling someone about DuckDuckGo and they thought it was Duck.com and they went to Google. Is Google using this to find people who make the mistake to Duck.com instead of DuckDuckGo?"

"Can't you do something about this? I keep going to Duck.com when meaning to visit DuckDuckGo.com They are using the DuckDuckGo name to get people to search Google."

This only started happening after I asked about the domain name. It used to point to a history page about Duck Corporation (previous name of On2 -- http://web.archive.org/web/20100802014055/http://duck.com/), similar to http://www.on2.com/, which was acquired by Google in the same acquisition.

Google should legitimately not sell it to me, though it would have been of course nice to do so when I first asked in 2010. I think an appropriate remedy would be to either point it nowhere, point it to the original page it had been pointed to for many years, or point it to the acquisition page (as http://on2.com still does) -- all things they do in other cases if you look at past acquisitions.

Just to be clear, it is only anti-competitive because it causes confusion, and relates to their core search product. The facts of the situation (that it switched shortly after I asked, and only seemingly that one domain) make it appear to be deliberate. And if it were not deliberate, I've brought this up many times and there has been ample time (including now!) to correct the situation.

With regards to being easy to add search engines to Chrome, see http://www.gabrielweinberg.com/blog/2011/02/usability-issues.... I've written up the differences extensively, with screenshots and explanatory notes.

Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by hahainternet on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:00AM (#4817823)
> Just to be clear, it is only anti-competitive because it causes confusion, and the facts of the situation make it appear to be deliberate. And if it were not deliberate, I've brought this up many times and there has been ample time (including now!) to correct the situation.

So if Google changes it they admit that they may have harmed you and you get a legal remedy. If Google doesn't change it you claim there's no reason not to and you get a moral argument.

Sounds like you're trying to construct a situation where you win and Google loses no matter what. How about just deal with the fact that it's not your domain? I quite like camping.com, doesn't mean I have the right to it.

Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by yegg on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:01AM (#4817830)
Changing it now isn't a legal admission of anything.

In any case, there would still be no useful legal remedy available to us. We don't make much money, so what would the damages be?

The last thing a startup wants to do is take a big company to court. You're just asking to be bled dry.

Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by davemel37 on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:06AM (#4817837)
I don't see how you can legitimately make a claim on a generic name. I also don't see how this is a monopoly issue. It is a trademark issue, which doesn't have much likelihood of winning. I think i'm gonna start my own search engine called searchsearchfind and than complain about CBS's search.com monopoly.
Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by Surio on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:49AM (#4817942)
I don't think he is making any such claim. Like I mentioned elsewhere, if you follow his full explanation, it is Google that is actually capitalising on this confusion and redirecting users to their own engine.
Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by davemel37 on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:58AM (#4817965)
The confusion (if it really exists) has nothing to do with Google. It has to do with DDG not protecting their turf. When they chose their name, they could have chosen thousands of others. This isn't and shouldn't be Google's problem and quite frankly comes off as a weakness that DDG ran with this story.
Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by Surio on Thursday November 22, 2012 @03:31AM (#4818016)
If you read @yegge's response (I reproduced it here)

This only started happening after I asked about the domain name. It used to point to a history page about Duck Corporation (previous name of On2 -- http://web.archive.org/web/20100802014055/http://duck.com/), similar to http://www.on2.com/, which was acquired by Google in the same acquisition.

Google should legitimately not sell it to me, though it would have been of course nice to do so when I first asked in 2010. I think an appropriate remedy would be to either point it nowhere, point it to the original page it had been pointed to for many years, or point it to the acquisition page (as http://on2.com still does) -- all things they do in other cases if you look at past acquisitions.

Effectively it is Google's fault because they are doing it now specifically in his case and not for others (as he mentions clearly)

Secondly, while it would be nice to pre-empt all angles and all possibilities etc., etc., but I don't think any of us can foresee every possible way something will come back to bite your backside in the future. So, no, I don't think that it is somehow DDG's fault that they did not foresee this and preempt it.

P.S: FWIW, google renamed themselves from googol to google because the VC mispelled their name on the cheque. Just goes to show that such things are a fact of life. People have every right to vaguely try to look up "Duck something" search engine. However, Google is definitely in the wrong for sneakily redirecting users back to their own engine in this case by misusing this vagueness.

Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by Surio on Thursday November 22, 2012 @03:13AM (#4817985)
[moved to correct place]
Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by prawn on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:19AM (#4817867)
"I keep going to Duck.com when meaning to visit DuckDuckGo.com"

Tell them that you called your search engine Duck Duck Go, registered DuckDuckGo.com, and for them to visit DuckDuckGo.com. It's not as though you were ever called Duck.com instead. This just sounds like a petty whinge otherwise. Sorry!

Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by Surio on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:46AM (#4817933)
Daniel meant to convey that he hears that line from other people who get to hear that line within their circles of recommendation -- effectively after the damage has been done.

Doesn't sound like a petty whinge according to me though at least if you follow his full explanation of Google actually capitalising on this confusion and redirecting users to their own engine.

Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by prawn on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:42PM (#4820118)
Capitalised on the confusion? They have hundreds of domains pointing to their main site. On2.com or whatever it is showed an acquisition notice because that was the company purchased. It's definitely possible that enquiring about the domain reminded them that they had it and should forward like the rest they owned.
Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by general_failure on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:27AM (#4817887)
Huh? Google has to sell you a domain which has nothing to do with your product.. because you asked for it? Wow.
Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by cpeterso on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:54AM (#4817953)
Gabriel, have you considered rebranding DuckDuckGo? If the name is affecting user adoption or perception, it can be changed.
Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by digitalengineer on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:37AM (#4817917)
Love DuckduckGo and totally understand the bullshit move Google made by letting it point to google.com. I for one think save-searching using DuckDuckGo has huge potential especially when Google starts selling the information they hold on you. Not for GoogleAds but for marketing purposes. Think about it: Wouldn't your health care insurance company like to know your entire search history? What would that be worth? You search for pain in abdomen a lot? Pop! Up goes your monthly payment. Crazy? I don't think so and I specialize in consumer and shopper marketing. You are totally honest inside that little google search box. It's not just health care and insurance, it's everything.
Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by iomike on Thursday November 22, 2012 @03:11PM (#4819853)
Your poor marketing with an unknown name is not Google's problem.
Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by tzury on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:25AM (#4817883)
Dear Gabriel,

I have been watching your work for quite a while, and from what I have been able to grasp, currently, your main advantage is the privacy.

Now I wonder if you ever considered instead of developing a new search platform, developing a user friendly privacy proxy platform and let Google and other search engines (including bing which your results relies heavily on it) do their job, while you keep your customer's privacy in the middle.

Have you?

Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by fauigerzigerk on Thursday November 22, 2012 @02:19AM (#4817866)
There's something else I'm starting to worry about. Some websites (e.g. The Financial Times) restrict access to their subscription only content to the Googlebot (and presumably Bing/Yahoo). Is that something you worry about? Do you just ignore that content or do you talk to the website owners if you feel they are important enough?
Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by timdorr on Thursday November 22, 2012 @01:40AM (#4817783)
I agree. Especially when I got to this part:

    In an interview on Wednesday, Weinberg said it is difficult to make his 
    DuckDuckGo the default search site in Google's Chrome web browser.
I just hit ⌘+' on my keyboard and selected duckduckgo.com from a drop down. I didn't even have to hit save and it starts working with DDG immediately. How is that difficult?
Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by fudged71 on Thursday November 22, 2012 @01:16AM (#4817735)
Why are you here? This is entirely relevant to HN. How is a small business that does things uniquely supposed to get users when their biggest competitor is actively making it difficult to try the other service out?

Regardless of whether their claims are true or not, that is.

Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by irahul on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:27AM (#4818255)
> Does anyone care about DDG anyway?

The number of votes and comments tell me people on this forum do care. Personally, I care because DDG is doing something ambitious and competition is good(it helps keep people in line). Also, even if I didn't care, I don't see a reason why I should shit on someone's hard work.

> They're trying to solve a completely imaginary problem,

Privacy isn't an imaginary problem.

> and they haven't got a hope in hell of creating a viable search engine as that costs billions of dollars.

Creating one from scratch will take time and money, and no, as blekko folks pointed out, it didn't take them billions. But DDG uses bing apis augmented with custom index.

Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by neya on Thursday November 22, 2012 @01:31AM (#4817760)
While I agree with you on the problem solving part, I feel you are a bit aggressive.

>Why is this article even on HN?

I think its relevant because PG wrote an article about "frighteningly ambitious ideas" and DuckDuckGo seems to be inspired from it.

Re:Google competitor DuckDuckGo says it's getting shut out by amitamb on Thursday November 22, 2012 @01:42AM (#4817792)
Is it PR bullshit? It probably is, but are their claims entirely wrong. If you see my comments, they are not entirely baseless.

Let's not kid ourselves, Google is a good company but they have to defend their position. Not just DuckDuckGo, but even your supposed billion dollar search engine will face same issues mentioned in the article. So this is not about the DuckDuckGo as a company but about monopolistic practices. Let's talk about that.