News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jolla Mobile: website launch and Sailfish OS sneak peek by mtgx on Wednesday November 21, 2012 @07:22AM (#4813940)
We'll see. I saw an interview with them this year, and something they said worried me. They basically admitted their OS would be heavily controlled by carriers, but they tried to spin it as "working very close with carriers". If that's the case, it might provide an even worse experience regarding carrier bloatware and whatnot than Android.

Plus, leaving the control up in the air, means that it could become as fragmented as the Linux world - which is much more fragmented than Android. At least you can run an Android app on virtually any Android-based phone.

To be honest, I'm more excited about Firefox OS. I even like its UI more than this, which looks like a mix of different UI ideas from different operating systems. Not that I have anything against borrowing ideas and building on them - it's just that I don't think the result is very good.

Re:Jolla Mobile: website launch and Sailfish OS sneak peek by MatthewPhillips on Wednesday November 21, 2012 @09:01AM (#4814225)
What is your expectation for the relationship between a manufacturer and carriers? The carriers are their customers. If they want to stay in business, they have to make their customers happy, like any other industry. The idea that they are going to put their foot down and strong-arm the carriers is not a realistic one. I take that comment to mean Jolla wants to stay in business.
Re:Jolla Mobile: website launch and Sailfish OS sneak peek by adityab on Wednesday November 21, 2012 @09:55AM (#4814429)
This is the American mindset.

They are targeting Europe and mostly Asia at the moment. Living in India, I know for a fact that most people don't buy smartphones locked into carriers.

We do have conracts tied with devices, but the market for them is very small in the case of smartphones.

It just doesn't make sense to commit for so long to a particular telecom company, because here, carriers compete a lot and people do want flexibility to switch from one carrier to another.

So no, I don't think jolla is at the mercy of carriers.

Buying a phone that you don't have complete control over is seen as stupid.

Re:Jolla Mobile: website launch and Sailfish OS sneak peek by recoiledsnake on Wednesday November 21, 2012 @09:08AM (#4814253)
Hopefully they take and stick to a stand that preinstalled carrier bloatware should be able to be uninstalled very easily and disallow always running services like on WP.

This is a happy medium between the hardline no-preinstalled-carrier-apps of iOS and the anything-goes Android phones.

Re:Jolla Mobile: website launch and Sailfish OS sneak peek by MatthewPhillips on Wednesday November 21, 2012 @09:13AM (#4814267)
Jolla has no clout. They can't take a stand on anything. The best they can do is build it into the system that all apps can be uninstalled and hope no one at the carrier brings it up.