>> you have no property rights in your Facebook account, which is wholly owned by Facebook
By this logic, do I also have no right to expect privacy when I mail a paper letter through the post office? After all, its sorting facilities are wholly owned by the government.
I honestly don't know what the framers would have said about that. If I shouldn't expect privacy there, the argument is done.
If I should expect privacy from the post office, there's a second issue:
>> and which you use for free only as a guest
By this logic, I should expect privacy from my cell carrier, because I pay to use their service, therefore my account and the data passing through it might be argued to be "mine".
>> in a bank safety deposit box, there was typically a contract specifying that you had certain ownership rights... [snip] ... some kind of right-to-information-privacy that supersedes the fact that it's my server and I own its contents.
Both of these parts of your comment suggest that I should be legally able to operate a service and specify in the user agreement that I won't give their data up for search without a warrant; that they have some ownership rights over their data.
Sadly, I think the government would assert otherwise. The only loophole I've heard used so far is to operate a service which, through encryption, actually can't access users' data. And for all I know, that will be declared obstruction of justice.
Your last point is an interesting one, though. If a provider specifically includes in their service policies a promise not to give up the user's data, then it seems like the provider would have a good claim when they attempt to quash subpoenas, even if the user themselves doesn't have any particular rights in the matter.
The cases are only uncovered by the fourth if we accept a narrow reading which somehow determines that "your papers" only applies to physical pieces of paper and that "be secure" only applies if the citizen would be deprived of access in the course of the search.
Those distinctions make no sense and, if applied, make the fourth amendment wholly technologically obsoleted in the very near future.
Is it a remotely logical position to argue that the founders were really concerned about government searches, seizures and surveillance, but only inasmuch as people were inconvenienced by those searches, seizures and surveillance?
That provided the English could have searched, seized and surveilled quickly, efficiently and entirely-on-the-sly the Revolutionaries wouldn't have been so hot about the issue?
I don't think that's a good state of affairs, but I can see how it logically makes sense. On HN we're often reminded that people have no right as users to any particular service from Google or Facebook, and the reason is that they don't own anything about the service or the data on it. Facebook could sell your data to advertisers, they could mail all your posts to the FBI without a warrant, whatever they want. So similarly there is no 4th-amendment right that you have relating to a search of Facebook, because it's not a search of your person or property, but of theirs. In the Founding generation this wouldn't have been an issue because it was not common to for a person to store significant amounts of their personal papers in a form where they had no ownership over them (even when you stored with a 3rd party, like in a bank safety deposit box, there was typically a contract specifying that you had certain ownership rights).
I do think there should be a fix to it, which will require implying some kind of rights that Facebook users have against government searches of Facebook targeted at that user (despite the user having no ownership in Facebook). But one wouldn't want that to go too far, because I can also see the property-rights argument: if I really do want to voluntarily mail the data on my server to the FBI, and I didn't sign a contract with the users saying I wouldn't, why should the users be able to stop me from doing so? You'd have to abrogate property rights with some kind of right-to-information-privacy that supersedes the fact that it's my server and I own its contents. Overall it seems like a situation that the Constitution's framers didn't imagine.