I (the OP) don't know why it was posted either, but the post is proven correct, so far. The great performance over the past 3 years was made possible by the terrible performance in 2007/09. The market still hasn't reached its high of the past decade. In fact, today's level of 1387 was first reached back in 1999, so that's 13 years with a flat trend and counting.
An index fund just mimics the market and has no research behind it. It's meant to perform just as the market does.
Anyway, I mostly disagree with OP. While I am not a firm believer in the efficient market hypothesis, I think it is very close. Index funds reflect the 'crowd-sourced' research from many very smart investors who have a lot on the line. I am 100% sure their combined research is more accurate than what I am willing to do in a few hours a month of my free time. Index funds are basically what give me the confidence I can safely invest my money into a large part of the American/World economy at a fair rate.