News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Debian must ship reproducible packages by pseudohadamard on Monday May 11, 2026 @04:14AM (#48092351)
Sure. The site appears to be a bunch of warm-fuzzies that could apply to almost any other measure you take, it's nothing specific to reproducible builds. As the original poster said "There was no bug or attack on Debian since 2007 that reproducible packages would prevent". In fact, it could be argued that reproducible builds lead to a reduction in security, not an improvement: They give an attacker an exact fixed memory layout for all of the binaries, so if you develop something like a ROP exploit for a copy on your local system you know that exploit will work on every other system as well because the binary layout is identical. It's a perfect monoculture where everything is vulnerable to the same exploit. It seems to have been something created by geeks to impress other geeks, without any considerations for whether it has any actual benefit or not.
Re:Debian must ship reproducible packages by stabbles on Monday May 11, 2026 @04:48AM (#48092572)
This comment is misinformed. Non-deterministic builds would also result in one tarball redistributed to all distro users. The ROP exploits don't work because of ASLR.
Re:Debian must ship reproducible packages by pseudohadamard on Tuesday May 12, 2026 @12:27AM (#48104191)
ASLR makes ROP attacks harder, it doesn't stop them, as a great many successful attacks have demonstrated. Heck, bypassing ASLR is taught to students at MIT... can't find the direct link ATM but here's a student assignment, https://csg.csail.mit.edu/6.S983/labs/aslr/.
Re:Debian must ship reproducible packages by uecker on Wednesday May 13, 2026 @01:36AM (#48118234)
This does not make your comment above less wrong.