News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If Pirate Bay Shut Down, Could Take BitTorrent With It by dmix on Friday February 13, 2009 @11:18PM (#480826)
I agree, on every private tracker there is a surplus of "seedboxes" or dedicated servers with gigabyte connections ready to keep the torrent community alive. These communities are often where the torrents found on public trackers originate. Most seedbox providers don't even not allow torrents from public trackers.

Although the average bittorrent user may be effected, a large migration, as a result of Pirate Bay shutting down, to private trackers would make it harder for the copyright owners to shut them down and track users because they are much more protected.

The nature of bittorrent and the huge communities surrounding them make it an almost impossible force to stop (outside of direct ISP intervention).

Re:If Pirate Bay Shut Down, Could Take BitTorrent With It by worldhello on Saturday February 14, 2009 @01:32AM (#480903)
I don't understand the extra level of protection... they are again offering torrents of copyrighted material. also the value would lie in the users sharing, which means that both the normal users and the law enforcement guys will get the same privileges, just as in the case of piratebay.
Re:If Pirate Bay Shut Down, Could Take BitTorrent With It by dmix on Saturday February 14, 2009 @01:44AM (#480913)
Private trackers are much more protected then public in many ways:

a) Its invitation only, if users give an invitation to a leecher/bad person then they themselves get banned, this creates an incentive to screen users thoroughly. Any person could go on a public tracker and have a list of the IPs of people sharing a particular torrent

b) Finding the trackers is usually difficult

c) Private tracker admins go to great lengths to anonymize data and protect their own identities

The law enforcement guys would have to be directly involved in these communities to gain privileges and also be on the edge of technical advancements. But given the fact that there are thousands of people for each law enforcement user (maybe hundreds of thousands) its nearly impossible for them to keep up. There are many similarities to drug trafficking.

Re:If Pirate Bay Shut Down, Could Take BitTorrent With It by Zev on Saturday February 14, 2009 @03:28AM (#480965)
http://www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en-us&... - not very hard to find. Or get into according to the top hit.