Re:Simple and Correct Snapshot Isolation
by we6251 on Monday May 04, 2026 @08:18AM
(#48007757)
Relatedly, another thing I found amusing/perplexing about SSI is that they already go to the effort of dealing with read-write dependencies in order to detect "dangerous structure" patterns (e.g. Sec 5.2 of [1]), and yet end up in a scheme that is somehow more complex (conceptually) than either plain snapshot isolation or basic WSI-style serializability.
It always seemed to me that, if you were already going to have to deal with the subtleties of read-write conflict detection (e.g. predicate reads, etc.), why not just default back to the simpler WSI-style approach. It is maybe an odd historical artifact that these algorithms ended up being layered in this way.
It always seemed to me that, if you were already going to have to deal with the subtleties of read-write conflict detection (e.g. predicate reads, etc.), why not just default back to the simpler WSI-style approach. It is maybe an odd historical artifact that these algorithms ended up being layered in this way.
[1] https://www.eecs.umich.edu/courses/cse584/archive/fall2023/s...