News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You can do it alone by ThomPete on Saturday November 17, 2012 @08:07PM (#4799509)
I wonder if there are more successful co-founder situations because there are more companies that start with co-founders?

A few single founders:

Overture (Bill Gross), eBay (Pierre Omidyar), Napster (Sean Fanning), Amazon (Jeff Bezos), AOL (William von Meister), Digg (Kevin Rose), SuccessFactors (Lars Dalgaard).

And then I guess there are many examples where one of the founders is actually driving the whole thing even though he/she has co-founders.

In some ways the whole discussion of co-founder/single-founder seem to be missing a bigger point which should be; What is needed to be a successful company?

How the equity falls out and who get to call themselves co-founders seem to be less important.

Re:You can do it alone by rdl on Saturday November 17, 2012 @10:26PM (#4799727)
Some of your examples are wrong (in the same way pg's essay points out -- most successful sole-founder businesses tend to have actually had cofounders)

Sean Parker was a cofounder of Napster.

WvM left AOL when it was nearly bankrupt in the early 80s; a team (including Steve Case) basically restarted the company. I'd either ignore this case or consider it a cofounder case.

Pierre Omidyar left eBay quite early, and raised money even earlier (including hiring Meg Whitman); it's a good example, but probably not as relevant today.

Overture/GoTo was part of Bill Gross's IdeaLab, which is a pretty unique situation. I don't think I'd call Bill Gross a solo founder there; he may have been the solo founder of IdeaLab.

Digg, probably not in the "successful" camp.

Amazon is a good example of a successful single founder. SuccessFactors too, even though I know ~nothing about their business other than it being highly successful -- it seems like a black box inside.

Re:You can do it alone by ThomPete on Saturday November 17, 2012 @11:30PM (#4799838)
I know Lars personally the others are actually solo founders. Sean Paker didn't found napster.
Re:You can do it alone by rdl on Sunday November 18, 2012 @12:03AM (#4799897)
Napster is probably most accurately described as originally conceived of by Shawn Fanning, but the company was founded by Shawn Fanning, Sean Parker, and John Fanning (Shawn's uncle), and Jordan Ritter is often considered a co-founder (who is IMO probably the strongest of the team).

It's not as complex as "who founded PayPal" (merger between two companies). Or anywhere near as complex as Facebook.

No one is arguing that a single person can't create software. (and, the "invention" aspect of creating a new product is almost always solitary!)

pg's argument (and the general argument here) is that to grow to a big, successful business, cofounders are highly correlated with success. That has to do with everything after the initial idea.

Re:You can do it alone by ThomPete on Sunday November 18, 2012 @06:59PM (#4802164)
But see this is kind of my point.

Solo vs. co-founder isn't really the question here.

It's not that it's harder to be a single founder, it's that it's difficult to even get a company up and running co-founders.

Re:You can do it alone by erichocean on Saturday November 17, 2012 @11:26PM (#4799836)
And then I guess there are many examples where one of the founders is actually driving the whole thing even though he/she has co-founders.

This is THE confusion in my opinion. Founder + startup team is not even close to the same situation as actually having multiple founders (Google is probably the best example for actually having more than one founder).

I don't know why pg actively conflates the two, but he doesn't hide it. In his essay, he talks about how you can't trust a founder "who can't even convince his own friends". Well sure, but how does convincing a friend suddenly make the friend a co-founder? Answer: it doesn't.

Re:You can do it alone by karamazov on Sunday November 18, 2012 @12:31AM (#4799951)
The distinction between a founder and an employee is that founders take on substantially more risk. If you convince your friend to join your company when you've just started it (or when it's a week or a month old), he or she is taking on just as much risk as you are and is a founder. It doesn't matter if it was "your idea" - they're taking a large risk, and they'll have a huge impact on how the company develops.
Re:You can do it alone by ThomPete on Sunday November 18, 2012 @04:40AM (#4800298)
its not even that simple