Re:Richard Dawkins and The Claude Delusion: The great skepti...
by bastawhiz on Saturday May 02, 2026 @07:11PM
(#47991530)
> the same principles a human brain does
This is exactly the crux of my comment. Which principles? Which human brain? If I lobotomize a human, and they lose some cognitive ability, are they still conscious? If I give someone drugs that inhibit their ability to feel emotion, are they still conscious? If yes, then surely those things are out of scope for what "consciousness" means.
Again, if you want to use abstractions like this, you need to define what they are.
This is exactly the crux of my comment. Which principles? Which human brain? If I lobotomize a human, and they lose some cognitive ability, are they still conscious? If I give someone drugs that inhibit their ability to feel emotion, are they still conscious? If yes, then surely those things are out of scope for what "consciousness" means.
Again, if you want to use abstractions like this, you need to define what they are.