Re:If engineers were journalists
by jamesjporter on Saturday November 17, 2012 @04:13PM
(#4799016)
The problem with 6 is that often the PDF of a research article is behind the paywall of the journal that published it. I agree that news organizations often do a horrible job of citing their sources for science coverage though; they could at least link to the journal's webpage for the abstract.
Re:If engineers were journalists
by kumarski on Saturday November 17, 2012 @04:09PM
(#4799006)
I think there's a chance for a compromise. A chance for journalists to have an engineer's quantitative veracity coupled with qualitative polish. I would cite Christopher Hitchens as an example.
Re:If engineers were journalists
by alanctgardner2 on Saturday November 17, 2012 @04:26PM
(#4799047)
I meant this specifically as a dig at this article. Personally, I've really enjoyed everything Randall Munroe has ever written; they're educational and relatively accurate, but they have a charm that a lot of writing lacks. Never read Hitchens or Feynman, but my understanding is that many technical people can also write quite well.
Re:If engineers were journalists
by goostavos on Saturday November 17, 2012 @05:41PM
(#4799186)
Feynman is one of those writers who's voice comes clearly through the text. All of his writing carries a very specific rhythm with it. Surely You're Joking Mr. Feynman is an absolutely fantastic read -- doubly so if you have any interest in the history of the Manhattan Project. It's usually painted as a completely serious affair, so reading feynman's account of goofing around with security and trying to sneak codes to his wife brought a very human side to the history. I highly recommend all of his writings.
Re:If engineers were journalists
by wam on Saturday November 17, 2012 @04:25PM
(#4799040)
Hmm. Stay away from words that carry connotations? That's what words do. Narrative journalism exists because we are storytellers, culturally if not innately.
Producing tools that help analyze and interpret media narratives is a good idea, but it's also a hard problem that doesn't show signs of being eased by crowdsourcing or noun/verb extraction. Fact-checking has already been completely politicized: What's bare fact to one person is obvious bias to another. You can certainly classify bias and hyperbole from your point of view. But even in peer-reviewed scientific publications you find bitter fights over "theory-loaded" paradigm biases.
Alongside this I'd like to know what you think journalists do well?
Edit: For a sociolinguistic perspective, see Lakoff (both of them). On the representation of "fact," Ian Hacking has an excellent book, "Representing and Intervening" which looks at Kuhn, Popper, Feyerabend, etc.
Re:If engineers were journalists
by kumarski on Sunday November 18, 2012 @10:37AM
(#4800727)
Maybe my protest is more against eye-grabbing-headlines than connotation...
Now that you've put it that way, the word journalist might be too broad in its definition. I think there are good and bad journalists with different positive skill sets.
I wrote the blog post after seeing too many scientific topics where journalists were inaccurate. This doesn't represent all journalists.
I think photo and video journalists do a particularly good job of news casting. Sometimes their content becomes described inaccurately. The napalm girl photo of Vietnam is a good example of this.
Thanks for the comment. Just checked out the book.
Re:If engineers were journalists
by rflrob on Saturday November 17, 2012 @04:37PM
(#4799067)
I'm not---and never have been---a journalist, but this piece is assuming that journalists are, by and large, happy with the state of reportage today. Yes, it would be great if you could exhaustively fact check every piece, or carefully and skeptically examine every assumption and statement a source makes, but when your editor is breathing down your neck because the presses are running, and you still haven't turned in your article, standards slip. I suspect that many (though not all) of these points are things that get taught over and over in journalism school, but there are eventually quality and quantity trade-offs, and if there's little incentive for the extra quantum of quality, then it's only rational that quality would win out.
Re:If engineers were journalists
by kumarski on Sunday November 18, 2012 @10:30AM
(#4800713)
I could see how the writing would indicate that.
We can't exhaustively fact check our pieces, but we can at least link to our sources. Maybe false information is the cost of doing business in high speed journalism?
If the author used the article, they have access to it, as well as the bibliography of that article.
Producing tools that help analyze and interpret media narratives is a good idea, but it's also a hard problem that doesn't show signs of being eased by crowdsourcing or noun/verb extraction. Fact-checking has already been completely politicized: What's bare fact to one person is obvious bias to another. You can certainly classify bias and hyperbole from your point of view. But even in peer-reviewed scientific publications you find bitter fights over "theory-loaded" paradigm biases.
Alongside this I'd like to know what you think journalists do well?
Edit: For a sociolinguistic perspective, see Lakoff (both of them). On the representation of "fact," Ian Hacking has an excellent book, "Representing and Intervening" which looks at Kuhn, Popper, Feyerabend, etc.
Now that you've put it that way, the word journalist might be too broad in its definition. I think there are good and bad journalists with different positive skill sets.
I wrote the blog post after seeing too many scientific topics where journalists were inaccurate. This doesn't represent all journalists.
I think photo and video journalists do a particularly good job of news casting. Sometimes their content becomes described inaccurately. The napalm girl photo of Vietnam is a good example of this.
Thanks for the comment. Just checked out the book.
We can't exhaustively fact check our pieces, but we can at least link to our sources. Maybe false information is the cost of doing business in high speed journalism?
Thanks for the comment.