Re:Lyft, SideCar, and Uber all slapped with $20K fines from ...
by Zak on Thursday November 15, 2012 @04:55PM
(#4790991)
Crappy oversight is better than no oversight.
I don't care about oversight. I care that the taxi I get in to doesn't crash.
I don't have a lot of faith that regulators will do a good job reducing the probability of that outcome. I think they're likely to be corrupt, incompetent, apathetic or some combination of the three.
I do have a lot of faith that insurance companies will do a good job maximizing their own profits. Those that fail to do so will cease to exist. If we can tie insurance company profits to my taxi not crashing, I think they'll do a near-optimal job of reducing the probability of that outcome.
I agree that $1M seems low for a taxi. That doesn't even cover one wrongful death.
My point is, by delegating regulation of cabs to the insurance markets, you don't make the market any more transparent or efficient; instead, you cede it to private businesses who can make arbitrary decisions with no oversight at all.
Crappy oversight is better than no oversight.