News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Message Oriented Programming by seanmcdirmid on Thursday November 15, 2012 @01:19PM (#4789915)
You just aren't trying hard enough. The first OO language (SketchPad '62) was constraint based (visual and based on prototypes). Then there was ThingLab (Borning, 78?). And for my own work, check out SuperGlue (ECOOP 2006, OOPSLA Onward! 2007). No methods to be seen...and still very OO.

Incompatible or orthogonal? Message passing is primarily an issue of software architecture (using Garland's definition) while OOP is more of an issue of linguistic abstraction.

OOFP is definitely possible, like say Moby or OCAML. The distinction between OOP and FP is hardly as black and white as you think.

Re:Message Oriented Programming by jerf on Thursday November 15, 2012 @03:19PM (#4790526)
With all due respect, I think you need to stop glancing over my posts and looking for things to pick at with all possible speed, and maybe spend a bit of time actually reading them, before you go jumping all over them any more. Your last paragraph in particular is pretty much proof positive you did not actually read the post you are replying to.
Re:Message Oriented Programming by seanmcdirmid on Thursday November 15, 2012 @03:53PM (#4790686)
I did read your post, I was disagreeing with this:

> They can't be peers, they have fundamentally different ideas about what is most important.

Re:Message Oriented Programming by RickHull on Thursday November 15, 2012 @01:57PM (#4790129)
For what it's worth, Sketchpad is described by wikipedia as a program and not a language, and moreso it "pointed the way forward" to OOP, in that Sketchpad included the concept of "master drawings" (read: classes) which could be instantiated into duplicates, such that when the master drawing changed, any previously instantiated duplicates would be changed accordingly.

ThingLab is described by wikipedia as a programming environment implemented in SmallTalk. In both cases, I think you are describing environments to play around with user-created objects moreso than languages.

Do Sketchpad or ThingLab have grammars?

Re:Message Oriented Programming by seanmcdirmid on Thursday November 15, 2012 @02:15PM (#4790229)
Well, what is a language then? My opinion is that any abstraction layer that shapes thought and allows for the expression of new abstractions is a language in its own right. If it has a textual syntax, great! But this isn't necessary. It might be a programming environment that exposes new or different metaphors from its underlying host. An object system in Scheme is defining a new language, an enhancement of Scheme, that happens to be OOP.

SketchPad is a language, just a very inexpressive one that is not targeted at traditional programmers. ThingLab defines new metaphors and such, programming in ThingLab is a distinct programming experience from Smalltalk. Heck, even Bad Piggies is defining an inexpressive language in the context of a game, or think scripting in LittleBigPlanet.

Re:Message Oriented Programming by RickHull on Thursday November 15, 2012 @02:31PM (#4790304)
I agree that you can "program" in these environments. But I disagree that they are languages. Perhaps I'm not thinking hard enough.
Re:Message Oriented Programming by seanmcdirmid on Thursday November 15, 2012 @02:41PM (#4790362)
This is probably because what makes a "language" is fairly fuzzy. There is probably no hard line where a abstraction layer goes from just being a user interface/environment/library/notation to a language.