Re:Lyft, SideCar, and Uber all slapped with $20K fines from ...
by sk5t on Thursday November 15, 2012 @02:25AM
(#4787589)
I made some remarks elsewhere in this thread about the term "unfair," and AFAIK it usually refers to anyone doing work outside the reach of the protestor's collective bargaining agreement.
"We have rigged the market to our satisfaction, and it would be unfair of you to alter that comfortable dynamic."
Re:Lyft, SideCar, and Uber all slapped with $20K fines from ...
by eli on Thursday November 15, 2012 @01:26PM
(#4789946)
The licensing proves to the agency that the drivers are drug tested and insured instead of simply taking Uber's word for it. I think it is unreasonable to expect that regulatory paperwork doesn't apply to you just because you're probably in compliance anyway.
Re:Lyft, SideCar, and Uber all slapped with $20K fines from ...
by viscanti on Friday November 16, 2012 @11:52AM
(#4794594)
This doesn't seem to be an issue of regulatory paperwork though. What does double licensing accomplish and what does it actually mean? I'm all for fines if they're found using unlicensed drivers. I guess I don't know that it's necessary to double drug test the drivers though. I don't think the issue here is filling out a permit, I think it's a matter of "what does that mean". If asked, they should probably be required to show that all their drivers are properly licensed. If their drivers are all properly licensed, I don't see what requiring Uber to be licensed accomplishes.
It's not a question of "probably in compliance". If Uber is using unlicensed drivers (which I haven't heard any evidence of), they should be fined. If they are using 100% properly licensed drivers, I think this is a non-story.
I don't think it's a degree of how onerous the requirement is. It's more a matter of what does it accomplish? There's not a precedent for double covering in the industry, and Uber certainly isn't gaining a competitive advantage because of it. It seems strange that they're lumped in with the other two services who clearly use unlicensed drivers.