Re:Rob Pike on Object Oriented programming
by enqk on Thursday November 15, 2012 @02:58AM
(#4787673)
Oh I worked with the guys he's talking about. They never start with data, they never even consider talking about data. Their world is the world of categories and taxonomies. They treat everything as an organism and favor class diagrams to data flow charts.
Re:Rob Pike on Object Oriented programming
by Evbn on Thursday November 15, 2012 @11:33PM
(#4792406)
Rob Pike is insanely good at what he does. But along the way he maintained insane ignorance about everything he doesn't do. Unfortunately, he forgets to confine his opinions to the important areas where he is knowledgeable, and has grown defensive about the world straying away from his domain. Hence the nonsensical rants against OO and type theory that put incoherent words in the mouths of his straw men.
Contrast to someone like Simon Thompson, toiling for decades on a marginalized language (Haskell) for decades, yet never wasting time insulting people who ignore his work. In fact, he praises his team for avoiding the distrsctions and hassles of attaining popularity before his work is perfected
He says:
OO zealots are afraid of data. They prefer statements or constructors to initialized tables. They won't write table-driven tests.
Who the fuck is Rob Pike talking about? The article he links at the top does not touch on these points. He's created a straw man and is attacking it.
I think Grandpa Rob is getting sick of all the kids on his lawn.