--
Sony’s strategy never comes together as a cohesive whole because their engineers are constantly in competition with each other to become famous for creating the next big proprietary format or gadget. There are so many proprietary formats or unnecessary electronics coming out of Sony that it makes Sony’s overall strategy and identity very confusing. The engineers all want to be the guy who creates something as big as the Walkman or PlayStation, they are all competing for that recognition inside of the company. However their ideas are created based on the love for technology, not long-term profitability.
On April 2012, Hiroko Tabuchi wrote an article to the New York Times saying, “Sony remains dominated by proud, territorial engineers who often shun cooperation. For many of them, cost-cutting is the enemy of creativity — a legacy of Sony’s co-founders, Mr. Morita and Masaru Ibuka, who tried to foster a culture of independence. But the founders had more success than recent executives in exerting control over division managers.”
--
This is certainly plausible, even if it's unfair to blame an engineering focus for Sony's failures. How else can you explain the fact that they STILL insist on using insane proprietary standards like ATRAC and even new Sony devices like the Vita use custom storage instead of standard (far less expensive) storage formats like SD cards? The fact that the PS3's absurd design got greenlit and made it all the way to ship is further evidence that engineers are given freedom to make myopic technology-focused choices.
I don't know anything about the corporate culture at Sony, but I had assumed that their relentless, senseless pursuit of proprietary formats and interfaces (among other customer-hostile stupidity like the CD rootkit scandal) was a sign that wacky Sony marketers were running the show, not engineers.
Because pursuing a proprietary format is generally a terrible engineering decision. If your product has to touch the outside world in some way, and there's already a de-facto standard way of doing that touching, you'll generally get your product done sooner and cheaper by using the de-facto standard. And the product will work better for the user, too. That is to say, it will be cheaper to make and it will also be worth a higher price. What engineer could say no to that?
If those decisions were driven by engineers, they must come from a very different engineering culture than anything I'm familiar with. Even if this really is the fault of engineering amok, blaming "arrogant corporate culture" might communicate the situation more clearly than blaming "engineers."
System level: boards are mostly not self contained modules but designed all together (I have just seen some Yamaha design that essentially uses board to board connector and whole connected board as jumper wire). Lots of glue logic placed on random boards of whole system. Many instances of mostly empty single-sided boards with only connectors and jumper wires. Complex interconnect topologies between separate boards.
In my opinion this comes from history of Japanese electronics manufacturing, they after all started doing SMT in 60's or 70's. All this looks to be optimized for small scale prototyping runs and custom robotic assembly of large series, while most western designs are optimized towards mid-scale series using existing automation. Generally you get designs that look like simple Chinese designs optimized for large scale manual assembly (toys etc.), but are orders of magnitude more complex.
Look inside random DVD drive (as most of them are ODM'd by Sony, and by the way, when you want to buy new DVD drive try to find one that has Sony brand, as it is significantly cheaper) to see what I mean, in almost any HP laser printer it is painfully obvious which part is designed by HP and which is unmodified part of Canon's print engine (although there it is mostly because of different manufacturing processes).
Well, I agree with you but look at Apple. They have been using proprietary connectors for most of their existence (mid 80s everything had to be made for Apple computers) and now the do the same silly thing with their iPads and iPhone connectors. Even their monitors do not have HDMI connectors! Sony certainly think of themselves as being competitors with Apple, and they see, I believe, no issue to take the same stance as them and make proprietary stuff all the way.
Apple has some proprietary stuff, but it's not that crazy. Apple used SCSI, standard floppy disks, cd drives, etc. Their floppy drives had extra features (like the eject motor), but the drives worked with bog standard floppy disks. Mini display port is a standard, so it's not that bad. When they ditched all the legacy stuff, they went with USB instead of inventing their own. Firewire was a standard too. They moved to Ethernet with the rest of the world, and used/promoted WiFi (even thought they had their own term for it).
Apple did how their custom ADC for a few years though.
But Sony is... in another world. They pushed SACD (technically a standard but no one cared), MiniDisc, Beta, Memory Stick, Memory Stick Duo, Memory Stick blah, the custom PSP discs, their proprietary music format, all sorts of stuff. They didn't use VHS-C mini video tapes, they used their own competing format. I believe they used their own MiniDV type format for a while. They had their own interconnect to connect their receivers to TVs for controlling things (not video, but turning on/off, volume, etc).
Firewire 400 had a standard connector, and it worked very well. Sony decided the connector was too big for their tiny camcorders, so they made their own. It was the little 4 pin FireWire connector that didn't pass power. That's the one most PC laptops later adopted, making it useless for external drives. Sony's connector, which they invented their own name for (i.Link 1394), had to be adopted into the standard because it became so common from Sony pushing it so much.
Sony and Apple have both lived in their own worlds (to a degree). What Sony is learning now is that when you're not on top that becomes a huge liability. Apple learned that when they nearly bankrupted themselves in the mid 90s.
Second, Apple tends to follow its own standards (e.g. iPod dock connector, magnetic power cord thing). Sony not only uses proprietary interfaces, it's inconsistent about them. E.g. At one point they had a range of MP3 players none of which used the same connector as another or earlier generation products.
Eventually Sony bended to the MP3 trend by releasing a new MiniDisc player with MP3 compatibility. Remember CD players that would play burned CDs of MP3 files? Sony's worked by hooking the device up to your computer where it would transcode the MP3s into a proprietary Sony format and then put those on the disc. It was one step above setting the thing up next to your speakers and pressing "record".
They did the same kind of nonsense with flash based MP3 players, where they never made any kind of dent for the same reasons. Their devices wouldn't play MP3s natively until (I believe) years after the iPod came out.
They said what they have so often: "damn the torpedoes, full steam ahead". What they keep finding out is that no one is following them, and the torpedoes are really doing damage to their ship.
BluRay is the only thing I can remember them winning on. It was technically superior, but it also got a huge boost from the PS3 (which, remember, they were selling at a $250-$300 loss at first). Even then, as people shift to BluRay the market is crumbling to streaming video.
I worked in TV Product Planning for a long time. There was virtually no contact with the content arms. It was remarkably hard to work with them even when we wanted to. If anything while I was there there was too little co-ordination and collaboration and too much of different parts of the company fighting or just going in opposite directions.
This is symptomatic of a dysfunctional organization. Not a content vs hardware problem.
http://appleinsider.com/articles/10/11/27/sony_adopts_then_d...
Is your comment just speculation?
I worked for Sony Computer Entertainment for a period around 2005. I can partly see the "engineering-centric in a bad way" thing, but to put the blame there for Sony failing to launch an MP3 player before Apple... Seriously, Sony Music killed it of course.
Sony has only one real problem: Sony. Merging an entertainment conglomerate with a hardware company was a dumb idea, because every product manager at Sony now has to get approval from two completely different companies with two completely different cultures in order to ship anything. At Sony, if the technology isn't proprietary enough, the DRM isn't annoying enough, or there are no clear opportunities to give the customer an enema with a fire hose, the product doesn't fly.
Blaming the engineers, wow. Good one.