News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Mark Cuban is wrong about Facebook by mikejsiegel on Wednesday November 14, 2012 @05:52PM (#4786049)
How is the relationship suppose to be beneficial to Facebook? No one signs up for Facebook to keep in touch with their favorite brands, they sign up to keep in touch with friends. Facebook allows brands to communicate to their users but their added benefit hardly helps FB at all. The only way it does help Facebook is if they monetize these relationships, which is what Facebook is attempting to do. I'm not sure there is legit proof that FB has decreased Fan Page outreach organically (the only way you could claim they're "abusing" the relationship - I don't see an issue with FB charging brands to reach more fans non-organically.

Mark Cuban isn't God, I don't think this is a "huge" signal at all. IMO, Cuban's critiques of YouTube have been similar - which I feel have also been proven wrong with time.

Re:Why Mark Cuban is wrong about Facebook by loceng on Wednesday November 14, 2012 @08:28PM (#4786614)
Brand pages are content for users, and it keeps people on Facebook instead of seeking out the brands and interaction elsewhere. There is no reason brands need to be on Facebook. If it now means being charged $3,000 to temporarily reach 1 million fans (and who knows of what quality level or fanaticism level) then they may question if it's worth it to them, and they are starting to. These brands who built up millions of likes on Facebook could just have a different system, that doesn't need to be connected to a central platform.

They are doing it the wrong way, though I don't care to help Facebook so I won't comment here as to how they should be doing it.

Re:Why Mark Cuban is wrong about Facebook by loceng on Wednesday November 14, 2012 @08:30PM (#4786621)
Also, the term organic vs. non-organic -- the posts that reach a person's feed, organically, is set by the algorithm Facebook determines; It's not so organic.
Re:Why Mark Cuban is wrong about Facebook by mikejsiegel on Thursday November 15, 2012 @10:55AM (#4789083)
Organic in the sense of how it's used in the industry. Google's search algorithm is set by Google but when talking about the search results people tend to differ between "organic" and paid.

The difference here is that "organic" is considered Google's and Facebook's best attempt to show their user what is most relavent to them. Some speculate that both companies are modifying these results to optimize paid results but there is no smoking gun that is true.