Re:XOR'ing a register with itself is the idiom for zeroing i...
by 3form on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @03:57AM
(#47860493)
I think an even more likely explanation would be that x86 assembly programmers often were, or learned from other-architecture assembly programmers. Maybe there's a place where it makes more sense and it can be so attributed. 6502 and 68k being first places I would look at.
Re:XOR'ing a register with itself is the idiom for zeroing i...
by richrichardsson on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @04:13AM
(#47860601)
For 68k depending on the size you're interested in then it mostly doesn't matter.
.b and .w -> clr eor sub are all identical
for .l moveq #0 is the winner
Re:XOR'ing a register with itself is the idiom for zeroing i...
by bonzini on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @09:06AM
(#47863013)
6502 doesn't even have register-to-register ALU operations, there's no alternative to LDA #0.
8080/Z80 is probably where XOR A got a lead over SUB A, but they are also the same number of cycles.
Re:XOR'ing a register with itself is the idiom for zeroing i...
by zahlman on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @08:51AM
(#47862853)
GP seems to think it strange that "x86" would actually not have a performance difference here.
I think this might just be due to not realizing just how far back in CPU history this goes.
Re:XOR'ing a register with itself is the idiom for zeroing i...
by wongarsu on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @09:31AM
(#47863365)
In a clockless cpu design you'd indeed expect xor to be faster. But in a regular CPU with a clock you either waste a bit of xor performance by making xor and sub both take the same number of ticks, or you speed up the clock enough that the speed difference between xor and sub justifies sub being at least a full tick slower
The former just seems way more practical
Re:XOR'ing a register with itself is the idiom for zeroing i...
by dbdr on Wednesday April 22, 2026 @09:57AM
(#47863724)
Even if they take the same number of ticks, shouldn't xor fundamentally needing less work also mean it can be performed while drawing less power/heating less, which is just as much an improvement in the long run?
It could also be as a result of most people working in assembly being aware of the properties of logic gates, so they carry the understanding that under the hood it might somehow be better.