News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Contra Benn Jordan, data center (and all) sub-audible inf... by logicprog on Monday April 20, 2026 @12:51PM (#47837006)
I don't think saying "as a general rule, data centers don't use remotely enough water to be any kind of significant threat, when you see through the accounting games, media hype, and look at things in a proper context" is made wrong or misleading by admitting that there are a few exceptions.

> That's fine for the moment when he wrote the article, but if I'm evaluating a proposed data center in my local area, I don't know what bucket it falls in. Is it the exception or the norm?

It does help you set your priors though, and not fall for the "all AI guzzles water, and DCs are dehydrating every town they're in and are always bad, without doing the research" rhetoric that's driving DC bans around the country right now.

Re:Contra Benn Jordan, data center (and all) sub-audible inf... by samhclark on Monday April 20, 2026 @01:18PM (#47837491)
I think we agree? I can't tell if you meant this as additional support for what I wrote or as a rebuttal.

Regardless, yeah, I don't think that's wrong or misleading. I only meant to say that because there are exceptions now, there might also be more exceptions in the future. Which, to me, means it's important to evaluate each new local DC individually.

And your point about setting my priors is exactly what I'm saying, too.

Re:Contra Benn Jordan, data center (and all) sub-audible inf... by logicprog on Monday April 20, 2026 @01:47PM (#47837981)
Ah ok, we probably do agree then.