News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Understanding Like-gate by codeka on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @11:47PM (#4782066)
But the thing is, if I check in at Starbucks all the time, and I "like" their facebook page, etc, what's the point of showing me their promoted posts? I'm already buying their products.

How will the fact that I like Starbucks tell Facebook when I'm in the market for a new vacuum cleaner? I might search for vacuum cleaners on Google, but Facebook is going to have no idea that I'm even in the market for vacuum cleaners unless I go and "like" a bunch of vacuum cleaner pages (which I presumably found by searching on Google).

Re:Understanding Like-gate by unreal37 on Wednesday November 14, 2012 @12:24AM (#4782140)
If you check in at Starbucks, it's not Starbucks that would pay to talk to you, it's McDonald's. Just like Google, if you are searching "Starbucks", it makes no sense to show a Starbucks.com ad.
Re:Understanding Like-gate by johns on Wednesday November 14, 2012 @01:24AM (#4782268)
Don't sell the upsell opportunity short either. If you buy a lot of things at Starbucks, you could probably be more easily convinced to spend more on your next trip.
Re:Understanding Like-gate by ThomPete on Wednesday November 14, 2012 @06:11AM (#4782895)
Again you do not have the luxury of delivering the message in the moment when I am actually interested in an answer.

It might be better than TV adds but it's not that different.

Re:Understanding Like-gate by dtsingletary on Wednesday November 14, 2012 @02:31AM (#4782404)
An 'ad' isn't the only activity Starbucks would post. We're in a less traditional paradigm here. Starbucks can do ad-hoc market research, community building, announce products... Lots of things. Some of the other commenters build on this further through competitive analysis and predictive modeling. Over the next few years we'll see this go further as they better understand the cooperative nature of brands and likes.
Re:Understanding Like-gate by ThomPete on Wednesday November 14, 2012 @06:22AM (#4782915)
They are already doing these things.

As long as they can't deliver "suggestions to my question" then they haven't really done anything other than given me a more targeted add.

But targeted is sub-optimale compared to the feedback mechanism that's build into google intent based advertising.