Being extremely careful will only prolong the inevitable crunch. You're betting on a 1% hike that might be a 5% drop because some idiot in a bus ran over someone important. That 5% drop could clean you out.
If you're betting on sure things, which means you're cheating somehow, then options are your best bet. Hey, if it works for you, you've got a good racket going, but most people will be absolutely destroyed.
Buy a put and a call option for the same strike price. On both options place a trailing stop at a fixed point ( <- that's where skill / statistical analysis comes in ) After one of those two orders execute cancel the second order and place a new trailing stop at a lower value to prevent additional loss.
If the stock goes up you sell the put and ride the call until the price drops or you liquidate.
If the stock falls you sell the call and ride the put.
Your risk is total to the loss in time value of the option for the duration of your trade , and is capped at a maximum of the sum total of the two trailing limits on your initial purchase. If you would like me to run the numbers for it please give me a security and I can even tell you where to set your puts ( I have computer programs I use to calculate reasonable stops , and execute this particular strategy )
Anything bought on margin or of a derivative nature is like this. You can bust out hard.
The thing with buying an actual security is a 5% drop is only a 5% drop in value, whereas in an option a 5% drop could translate to a gigantic liability.
Options, on the other hand, are constantly declining to zero value. It's how they work. If you end up out of the money at the end of the day, you bust out on that bet.
Where you can really get screwed is going (naked) short. Lets say you shorted a "modest" $1000 worth of out-of-the-money GOOG options today with a 8% spread from strike. The $600 Dec 22nd puts right now cost $2.80, so you'd sell 4 contracts for $1120. 8% is plenty of cushion, right? As long as GOOG's price doesn't go down more than 8% before expiration, you'd have $1120 in your pocket. That's a huge drop and highly unlikely. An easy $1120, right? It worked last month and the month before, so why not this time?
But oops, lets say just like last time GOOG's earnings leak early because someone fat fingered an email or something, and the stock took an instant 12% haircut. That extra 4% below your strike price just cost you approximately $24 per share. You had 4 contracts, so your options were against 400 shares. You just lost $24 * 400 shares = $9600 in order to make an "easy" $1,120.
Now, consider the fact that many people are going to be looking to make more than $1,000 a month when trading options. More like $5,000-$10,000. Guess what -- if the market systematically crashes by 10% over a few days because Ben Bernanke sneezed during a speech you could be in the hole for hundreds of thousands of dollars depending on what positions you've taken.
Also, if you were to buy closer to-the-expiration options (say, ones expiring next week as opposed to next month), the per-contract costs go down by approx a factor of 10, so you have to sell 10x more contracts in order to get the same gain. But guess what, if your luck is particularly bad and something goes horribly wrong, you can multiply your losses above by a factor of 10. (Yes, Virginia, with options it is possible, nay, easy to have a 10,000% loss in a few minutes on a bad day.)
That's how you can get fucked. You keep selling short puts on positions you can't really cover comfortably, and rake in the dough. And then on one sunny otherwise uneventful autumn afternoon something weird happens, and Vegas, er, I mean, Wall Street, takes it all back, and much more.
Buying options is like gambling at a casino. Statistically you will just keep losing money because the house always wins - they have the edge - unless you play a game like poker with a bunch of suckers - where the casino still takes a nice chunk of your change.
Selling options is like being a casino without the ability to know what the statistics of the underlying distributions or their payoffs are. Nor do you have the ability to kick a guy out if he wins too big and too often. It's a casino without the control. And a casino without control - is a casino that goes bankrupt.
Also to further prove that your wrong. The SEC has rules in place requiring that investors are not allowed to have to mush risk in their portfolio. Had you done what you jsut claimed and did a naked short on GOOG with no protection you would have been required to either pony up a large cash reserve ( protecting your broker from the liability ). Most responsible brokerages won't even allow your trade to go through unless again you have a large enough portfolio to absorb any reasonable risk.
This by the way is only using options for speculation. They have lots of other useful purposes and you haven't even discussed things like covered calls and using options as insurgence against volatility.
You can get naked put option permission at many brokerages once you have done some trading. Also your point about stops is irrelevant: the way you get burned by short options isn't from a stock price slowly grazing down past your stop, it's when the value of the company objectively changes by 5-10% overnight or instantly intra-day due to some event or disclosure. The rarity of this situation is the very reason that the risk in short options is easy to ignore since you are selling insurance against tail risks and usually don't have to pay up to the buyer. (Covered calls can be viewed as 'income for the price of potential gains' or 'insurance for short sellers' depending on how you want to view it. The same argument applies on both types of options.)
Don't lie - the vast majority of options expire worthless. Your argument is like saying: "Oh if you buy that piece of shit penny stock and it goes up 1 penny - you'll double your money - no cash down!". Sounds an awful lot like a scam to me.
There are no free lunches. Anyone who say's otherwise - is lying.
1.http://www.google.com/finance/option_chain?q=NASDAQ:GOOG&... 2. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/majority
1. As of 13 November 2012 GOOG dropped by ~1% a $650 put options rose in price by $1.70 had you owned just one contract you would have made $170 your outlay for that would have been $1180 a one day gain of ~15% even subtracting the trading fee of $10.00 to buy and $10.00 to sell you made $150 for a $1180 outlay or 12% in one day on one stock. This particular transaction is very risky as there is no hedge against a decrease in the put price. You can do that, but it will take more time to explain then I have right now. My napkin math tells me you could have placed a less risky trade and make a cool $100 on a 1% change with a 1K investment (i.e. 10%) on one day with minimal risk (risk is if stock isn't volatile enough or trailing stops are set wrong) .