Problem is they go to far. As soon as they state that you can't make money in markets - they've just crossed into stupid territory. If that were true - the world would be efficient and no one would ever make any money, because everything would be priced correctly.
What is with people separating stocks from businesses. If you work at a business, you are by definition stating that the market you work in is not efficient and hence EMH is bullshit. It's like massive cognitive dissonance - stocks are completely separate in people's minds from the shit that actually gets done - it's insane. It's just like religion. I mean you can happily see someone flying in a plane and the next second they'll be telling you how god exists and how science is bad. YOUR IN A FUCKING PLANE! Your life depends on science and engineering and they state that you are wrong.
Markets are what I'd call "better than central" planning efficient. They are better than central planning - for example you are a young programmer - how will a government bureaucrat know that you should go start an app company - it's better if people figure out what to do themselves, because they know themselves the best and can on average pick careers more correctly than a "sorting hat". But they are still pretty crappy because people make shitty choices all the time.
I agree with all your points - sell-side is a great money maker for people who know their shit. Buffett is one example. He runs $60 billion in insurance float, with nearly $24 running reinsurance and mega-cat risk. He makes a lot of money. But unless you have the financial reserves to back up your claims - don't even bother.
Buy insurance if you wish to hedge yourself - otherwise - stay the hell away.
Of course this leads back to your main point being unchanged: only experts are going to have confidence in knowing what a "fair" price is for a business, so selling options (or using them in general) should be left to such experts.