On the gRPC-as-client-layer point, I want to make sure I understand. You're suggesting that between the OBI client SDK and the source service, there should be a gRPC layer, with generated gRPC adapters fronting each source? Or something else?
Worth noting either way: the spec doesn't dictate implementation. It defines operation contracts, binding sources, and the executor role. How an executor actually reaches a service is left open, so gRPC-based routing is a valid strategy within the spec regardless.
Thanks for sticking with this. This is exactly the kind of discussion I was hoping for. I really do appreciate it.
[1]: https://github.com/grpc/grpc-go/blob/06fc26a196350499dd0cf2d...
If you're open to it, I'd be interested in staying in touch as OBI evolves. I know you're not sold on the project, but critical voices willing to engage constructively for this long are rare and valuable regardless. If you ever want to poke at something or tell me where you think it's going wrong, I'm at https://x.com/clevengermatt, and there's the GitHub discussions.
Also “tasks.create” is morally a route. Eg grpc has web transports and autogenerated CLIs too; even without those, there’s no particular reason why the OBI “client layer” couldn’t just be, say, gRPC under the hood, with the OBI specs just being used to codegen adapters from the source protocol to gRPC. It would then immediately have a much more widely understood and supported client layer, with better performance, while remaining as simple to implement as the adapters to this new custom OBI runtime protocol.