News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bluesky has been dealing with a DDoS attack for nearly a ... by anon7000 on Friday April 17, 2026 @01:27AM (#47802699)
You’re saying a mastodon instance can’t vet DDosed?
Re:Bluesky has been dealing with a DDoS attack for nearly a ... by eukara on Friday April 17, 2026 @01:57AM (#47802848)
Truth is if mastodon.social gets ddosd the same as Bluesky I can still use the rest of the network fine. Proof is in the pudding. tons of instances that make up the fabric of redundancy. I think most people would be served better if Bluesky acted differently early with their rollout in a sharded manner?
Re:Bluesky has been dealing with a DDoS attack for nearly a ... by Charon77 on Friday April 17, 2026 @02:16AM (#47802954)
True. The only 'distributed' part of bluesky is in the PR. Otherwise there'd be more instances.

My mastodon account is not even on mastodon.social, because why would I, when I could have a home server closer to home

Re:Bluesky has been dealing with a DDoS attack for nearly a ... by genewitch on Friday April 17, 2026 @05:13AM (#47803970)
i get real tired of people trumpeting that bsky is distributed.

Can i run a private node? can i run a functional node completely within my network segment? because i can with gnusocial and misskey; i've never run mastodon; i am on fosstodon and a couple of other mastodon-likes.

bluesky is to discord what mastodon (fedi) is to IRC.

don't let the fact that most people use the main instances fool you, there's thousands (maybe tens of thousands) of instances. I haven't seen a tally recently, i forget the account that shows them for each "instance type", like pleroma, misskey, mastodon, pixelfed, whatever the reddit clone is, whatever the 4chan clone is, and so on.

anyhow when elon bought twitter mastodon surged. I hope they didn't spend millions upgrading the main instances because most of that dropped off because, you know, everyone's on twitter. only a few million on mastodon.

My whole point is, trying to shoehorn words like "distributed" into a system that i cannot run independently is, well it's just not distributed, that's all.

edit: maybe this is sour grapes because i never got an invite; but maybe i think it's just twitter with a different coat of paint and different buzzwords attached.

Re:Bluesky has been dealing with a DDoS attack for nearly a ... by pino83 on Friday April 17, 2026 @07:53AM (#47804918)
Two times some guys at Mastodon tried to convince me to try Bluesky.

I explicitly told them that I want something distributed and that's a high priority, not a nice-to-have.

Yesss, there's definitely some very cheeky marketing going on.

Re:Bluesky has been dealing with a DDoS attack for nearly a ... by throwaway290 on Friday April 17, 2026 @08:27AM (#47805184)
Blacksky and other instances of bluesky are not affected, what are you talking about?
Re:Bluesky has been dealing with a DDoS attack for nearly a ... by fsmv on Friday April 17, 2026 @10:28AM (#47806327)
Not true, they were down because they still use bluesky's relay
Re:Bluesky has been dealing with a DDoS attack for nearly a ... by yangm97 on Friday April 17, 2026 @09:40AM (#47805853)
This is half true. If mastodon.social goes down every single one of the accounts made on that instance go down as well. In truly decentralized protocols you own your identity and can take it elsewhere, for instance, in Nostr and SSB, a relay/pub going down is no big deal since you can connect to other servers and maintain communications.
Re:Bluesky has been dealing with a DDoS attack for nearly a ... by eukara on Friday April 17, 2026 @11:57PM (#47813018)
historic posts from the known network and (sometimes media, instance setting) are cached on your own instance in ActivityPub. interactions travel across the known network graph. if an instance vanished forever, overnight, there is at least an imprint of it across the network, albeit instance specific. that may be by design, there are jurisdictions that have people complying with laws and things. not sure how the ecosystems you mention deal with that in particular
Re:Bluesky has been dealing with a DDoS attack for nearly a ... by yangm97 on Saturday April 18, 2026 @09:05AM (#47815598)
That doesn’t answer the point I’m making. If the instance your account was made on explodes, YOU lose your social graph, wether some of your posts survive cached elsewhere is not relevant, your account is gone, and so are your connections.

You have no way to prove an account made after the original instance went down belongs to someone, that’s the issue with federated systems.

As for content moderation, in nostr relay operators such as nostr.build handle legal takedowns on a daily basis, SSB is a little trickier since it’s mostly p2p but pubs are still able to control what flows through them to some degree.

Re:Bluesky has been dealing with a DDoS attack for nearly a ... by eukara on Tuesday April 21, 2026 @12:01AM (#47844374)
the web, which also gets referred to as decentralized, suffers from the same proof problem. we have identity tied largely to dns. web sites can claim whatever. somewhere a line was drawn to indicate what matters most is creating something without a single point of failure?
Re:Bluesky has been dealing with a DDoS attack for nearly a ... by snailmailman on Friday April 17, 2026 @02:13AM (#47802940)
The people I follow on mastodon come from a wide variety of instances. While mastodon.social is the largest instance, most of the accounts I follow are elsewhere.

Granted, all the smaller instances are likely easier to DOS as they are small instances. But mastodon is actually decentralized. If any one instance goes down, everything else keeps working. Unlike Bluesky and ATProto which is more of a theoretical “could be” decentralized.

Re:Bluesky has been dealing with a DDoS attack for nearly a ... by direwolf20 on Friday April 17, 2026 @07:22AM (#47804710)
On the Fediverse you can even block mastodon.social and still have a well populated feed. This is not the case for bluesky.
Re:Bluesky has been dealing with a DDoS attack for nearly a ... by MrDOS on Friday April 17, 2026 @11:24AM (#47806940)
https://arewedecentralizedyet.online/ is a fun dashboard visualizing how decentralized the Fediverse/Atmosphere is/isn't.