Which is orthogonal to whether it is moral to arrange your affairs to pay only what is legally owed.
> The more effort people spend avoiding taxes, the more complicated the tax system will get as it attempts to close those loopholes.
Which is also orthogonal to whether it is moral to arrange your affairs to pay only what is legally owed.
This is the framework under which I consider tax avoidance to be unethical -- obviously if you do not support the society in the first place, you might disagree.
Then change the rules. We have a mechanism for that purpose.
It is not the courts.
>The more effort people spend avoiding taxes, the more complicated the tax system will get as it attempts to close those loopholes. The more complicated it gets, the harder it is to form a social contract that represents the best interest of the nation.
Also, I hadn't mentioned the courts once, and in fact stressed multiple times that I'm not talking about the legality of the situation.
This is an absurdity; what binds a society together is people forming actual relationships of mutual benefit with one another. Complex, formal institutions are an afterthought, and even more of an afterthought is paying some precise percentage of your income to the specific people who operate one of those institutions, so they can can pay others to construct roads (as though no other means could be found to facilitate the pouring of asphalt), or build prisons for the incarceration of people who ingest particular chemicals that some think are per se bad.
If anything, empowering excessively centralized institutions creates intense factional polarization which undermines societies, inhibiting the formation of substantive relationships and communities instead of sustaining them. Our present "culture war" is a clear example of this.
The sole substantive basis for functional societies is the willingness of people to participate in them. Theoretical doctrines of "social contracts" and "nations" are just post-hoc rationalizations.
The more effort people spend avoiding taxes, the more complicated the tax system will get as it attempts to close those loopholes. The more complicated it gets, the harder it is to form a social contract that represents the best interest of the nation.