News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Schools Never Taught Critical Thinking: AI Exposed the Lie by epgui on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @10:56AM (#47766485)
I don’t think you can really know this with such certainty.
Re:Schools Never Taught Critical Thinking: AI Exposed the Lie by tkgally on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @11:03AM (#47766578)
Here is one sign:

“... the most uncomfortable question here is not whether ChatGPT is making teenagers worse at thinking. It is whether the education system ...”

“This is not cognitive dissonance in any simple sense. It is something more structurally interesting ...”

“... opting out is not a principled stand. It is a competitive disadvantage.”

“The students are not confused. They are trapped.”

“... choosing not to use AI is not intellectual integrity. It is self-sabotage.”

“... the problem is not that education cannot protect against cognitive offloading, but that most education systems are not currently designed to do so.”

“... cognitive offloading is not a convenience. It is a developmental short-circuit.”

“... happening not through careful pedagogical planning, but through exhaustion...”

“... students are adopting AI not because they have been taught to use it critically, but because nobody has given them a compelling reason not to.”

“These investments are not philanthropic gestures. They are strategic plays ...”

“These are not neutral actors offering disinterested tools. They are companies with revenue models ...”

“... they are not just choosing a product; they are choosing a pedagogical philosophy ...”

“... Khanmigo is designed not to give answers directly. Instead, it employs a Socratic method ...

“AI did not break the system. It revealed, with uncomfortable clarity, what the system was always building toward ...”

Re:Schools Never Taught Critical Thinking: AI Exposed the Lie by nayroclade on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @11:12AM (#47766705)
Are you kidding? Check out the index page for this "blog": https://smarterarticles.co.uk/

A new long-form article, published every day, like clockwork, since the 1st of June 2025. All about AI, all attributed to the same author.

Congrats to him on finally getting this slop to the top of HN, I guess. Shame on everybody here for upvoting it.

Re:Schools Never Taught Critical Thinking: AI Exposed the Lie by masfuerte on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @11:13AM (#47766727)
Even if a human author has learned to copy the style of AI writing, I still don't want to read it.
Re:Schools Never Taught Critical Thinking: AI Exposed the Lie by Edman274 on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @11:30AM (#47766954)
> If your peers are using AI and getting better grades, opting out is not a principled stand. It is a competitive disadvantage.

> The students are not confused. They are trapped.

> In this environment, choosing not to use AI is not intellectual integrity. It is self-sabotage.

> Here is where the conversation gets genuinely uncomfortable.

> The culprit was not artificial intelligence. It was standardised testing.

> For them, cognitive offloading is not a convenience. It is a developmental short-circuit.

> This is not merely a problem of laziness or moral failure. It is a predictable consequence (...)

> These investments are not philanthropic gestures. They are strategic plays for long-term market dominance (...)

> These are not neutral actors offering disinterested tools. They are companies with revenue models (...)

> This is not a new insight. It is a well-established finding that anglophone education (...)

> (...) AI is not a threat; it is an upgrade.

> If, however, the purpose of education is to cultivate human beings (...) then the arrival of AI is not the crisis. It is the revelation that the crisis was already here.

> Not more bans. Not more surveillance software. Not more hand-wringing opinion pieces from adults who themselves rely on AI for their professional work.

> But the overreliance they fear is not a new phenomenon introduced by ChatGPT. It is the logical extension of an educational philosophy (...)

The irony here is that the AI generated article gives a full throated endorsement of using LLMs to generate slop; why should we believe that the guy who prompted the LLM to generate slop that says slop generation is good did not himself use the slop generator?

Re:Schools Never Taught Critical Thinking: AI Exposed the Lie by acesley180604 on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @12:29PM (#47767783)
API call failed after 3 retries: HTTP 429: The usage limit has been reached
Re:Schools Never Taught Critical Thinking: AI Exposed the Lie by Tepix on Tuesday April 14, 2026 @11:01AM (#47766553)
Have you read it? The style is horrible.