News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thoughtcrime in Britain by Nursie on Monday November 12, 2012 @08:54PM (#4775877)
"We are not (and should not be free) to: Insult people for no other reason than to cause them pain"

Why not? Your other points have some merit. This does not.

"The very fact that we have seen it and are debating it shows that it indeed caused offence."

So what? Really, so what? Some moron in a bedroom in Kent posted an offensive picture. And? Are you not adult enough to ignore it? Who cares? It's not like he punched someone.

"It was exactly the sort of behaviour that would cause a fight in a bar and as such would be illegal there too."

Except it wasn't said in a bar, it was published online. There are a lot of things people say to each other online that they wouldn't say in a bar in case it caused a fight. That is not the standard for free speech.

"Freedom to be nasty is not the same as freedom of expression."

Yes, yes it is, because where you draw the line of nasty is entirely subjective. Just look at all the people that think any expression of atheism, or talk of historical record as it applies to religion is insulting. You would have these off limits as well.

"I, too, believe in protecting free speech"

You really don't, otherwise you wouldn't support this arrest, however abhorrent or useless you thought the opinions expressed in it were.

There are no comments on this comment yet.