Hardware: Are the older models supporting the low energy mode of bluetooth 4? If not .. that'd be the reason, I guess.
The 4S was the first iPhone to support low-energy bluetooth.
Note that this use-case is handled specifically in the spec:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bluetooth_low_energy#Electronic...
Personally I haven't misplaced my wallet since I was a teenager but I guess this might be useful to some. It's not clear why they're limiting the IPhone/IPad hardware requirements to just the newest ones.