News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by _heimdall on Sunday April 12, 2026 @08:10AM (#47738750)
There's a whole ball of wax here that boils down to whether a society would rather be individualistic or collectivist.

Its a chicken and egg problem as well, the way we regulate and manage health care and health insurance (at least in the US) allows for costs to pretty easily bleed out to the rest of society. That implies that we must then be collectivist in other policies, though that is counter to many of the original goals of our country and the question is whether we changed those goals or inadvertantly built a system that requires changing gials after the fact.

We have a similar problem with immigration laws. Our immigration laws today are completely counter to what they once were, and counter to what is still written on the Statue of Liberty. We have immigration laws now that are necessary because of the welfare programs we implemented, even if we wanted to live up to the older ideals we couldn't without abandoning those welfare programs entirely.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by yonaguska on Sunday April 12, 2026 @08:18AM (#47738805)
The statue of liberty poem was never a legally binding immigration policy. Not to detract from your point, which I agree with.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by rayiner on Sunday April 12, 2026 @09:50AM (#47739638)
It was marketing that was installed on the statute of liberty in 1903, when the U.S. was already fully developed. It doesn’t reflect the original intent at all.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by AlotOfReading on Sunday April 12, 2026 @11:01AM (#47740532)
It was written in 1883, as part of fundraising for the pedestal. It might not reflect precisely the "original intent" of the statue, but it's very much in line with all of the other context.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by rayiner on Sunday April 12, 2026 @09:50PM (#47746618)
The statute of liberty was from a french admirer of the constitution and abolitionist. It was conceived at a time when Napoleon III had declared himself emperor. The connection to immigration was a completely unrelated glomming-on.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by AlotOfReading on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:17AM (#47747533)
Death of the author. People sailed under the statue to get to Ellis island, it's not a difficult connection to make. The location was known when the poem was presented in 1883, 2 years before the statue arrived in the US and the author volunteered for one of the numerous aid organizations helping jewish immigrants.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by rayiner on Monday April 13, 2026 @12:37AM (#47747655)
The fact that people used it after the fact for marketing an unrelated issue doesn’t have anything to do with the original intent of the statue. There was a lot of ret-conning American history in the late 19th to early 20th century as a result of mass immigration.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dghlsakjg on Monday April 13, 2026 @11:25AM (#47753378)
Things can come to mean something different from what their funders intend.

It happens all the time, especially with art, language and especially public monuments.

The Statue of Liberty’s connection to Ellis island is undeniable. The national museum of immigration is part of the same monument and run by the same staff.

It’s not ret-conning to say that the Statue of Liberty is indelibly linked - physically and symbolically - to mass migration of working and lower class people. It was the busiest port of entry for more than 60 years, and more than 20 million people entered there. There are uncountable contemporaneous accounts of immigrants viewing their passing the statue as a marker of the end of the voyage, and the beginning of their life in America.

One French guy funded it for one reason. 20 million others saw it as a symbol for something different in their lives.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by TimorousBestie on Monday April 13, 2026 @01:12PM (#47755078)
The full title of the statue is “La Liberté éclairant le monde”—it’s impossible not to see it as a symbol of the ideals of the Enlightenment spreading across the world. That’s the common philosophical ground of both American and French Revolutions, and from there the source of the friendship that the statue represents.

At least some minimal notion of hospitality with respect to migration is part of that Enlightenment. (Kant’s Perpetual Peace is emphatic about this; Derrida annotates the relevant section with fresh eyes in Hospitality vol. 1, the first lecture and ff.)

That said, I also agree with you that symbols are not fully formed at birth and it is not the case that what they represent never changes at all in the course of their history.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by Cpoll on Sunday April 12, 2026 @10:16AM (#47739964)
> a society would rather be individualistic

This is a bit oxymoronic. People are a bit too happy to pick and choose what they like and otherwise pretend they're an island to themselves, but it doesn't take a communist to see the contradiction.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by _heimdall on Sunday April 12, 2026 @10:39AM (#47740267)
You're assuming its a binary rather than a spectrum though. I wouldn't expect to find anyone who is entirely individualistic or entirely collectivist.

Plenty of people would agree they're willing to pay taxes and give governments the authority to build and maintain public roads, for example. That doesn't mean they would also then be okay with government taking over industry.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by Eddy_Viscosity2 on Sunday April 12, 2026 @11:43AM (#47741055)
> whether a society would rather be individualistic or collectivist

Like many of these sorts of choices, its false to think of it as binary because its about choosing a place on the continuum between them.

On the methanal risk issue, one possible compromise would to have places which can run free checks on booze for methanal. Not too different from the practice in France where you can bring in mushrooms you've collected to the pharmacist who can tell you which ones are delicious and which are death incarnate. But of course this would have to be a publicly funded service which america seems to loathe ("I'd rather go blind than have a single tax dollar go to free booze testing!")

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by _heimdall on Sunday April 12, 2026 @10:32PM (#47746899)
> But of course this would have to be a publicly funded service which america seems to loathe

This hasn't been my experience in the US over the last couple decades. Both parties like to complain about the other side, but they both spend money we don't have and are happy to fund new government programs as long as its their party's program.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by eru on Monday April 13, 2026 @10:06AM (#47752186)
> [...] its false to think of it as binary because its about choosing a place on the continuum between them.

Yes. It's not even a continuum: it has more than one dimension.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dualvariable on Sunday April 12, 2026 @12:56PM (#47741895)
> There's a whole ball of wax here that boils down to whether a society would rather be individualistic or collectivist.

Yeah, but the US seems to me to be one of the worst places for individual responsibility. Everyone expects their environment to be perfect safe, and they can behave with a large degree of personal negligence, and if anything goes wrong they want to sue anyone they can think of. And then corporations take defensive actions against that, and you wind up with "do not take Flumitrol if you are allergic to Flumitrol" kinds of warnings everywhere. It is "individualistic" in the most narrowly narcissistic sense, which I don't think is what the founders envisioned either.

Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dv_dt on Monday April 13, 2026 @10:49AM (#47752829)
The way I see it is that enabling individualism, perhaps through strongly collective rules is very different than individualistically segmenting all sorts of experiences and protections. The latter of which, as you have noted, may not result in individualism on any sort of practical level - especially if it just lets large corporations mow down all sorts of people segmented to an individual level of power.
Re:US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ba... by dv_dt on Monday April 13, 2026 @10:10AM (#47752238)
| We have immigration laws now that are necessary because of the welfare programs

They may have had an effect of causing a political discussion, but fiscally, immigration policy has little impact on welfare programs.