Re:France's government is ditching Windows for Linux, says U...
by redoh on Saturday April 11, 2026 @08:50AM
(#47730137)
The difference between this and Munich's attempt is that France has been building up gradually. They already run Tchap (Matrix-based) for government messaging, and the gendarmerie switched to Linux years ago with over 70k desktops. Munich tried a big-bang migration without enough internal expertise and caved under political pressure when MS moved their HQ there. Schleswig-Holstein in Germany is taking the same incremental approach now and seeing better results. The pattern is pretty clear: governments that treat it as a multi-year capability build succeed, those that treat it as a licensing swap don't.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:France's government is ditching Windows for Linux, says U...
by gib444 on Saturday April 11, 2026 @09:58AM
(#47730662)
> Munich tried a big-bang migration without enough internal expertise and caved under political pressure
Almost sounds planned to fail...
Re:France's government is ditching Windows for Linux, says U...
by gyulai on Saturday April 11, 2026 @11:25AM
(#47731405)
If anything, the lesson to learn from the LiMux failure has nothing to do with technology or with project planning + execution, but with politics. If you extort millions from government as a for-profit business, most of which ends up as pure profit, there is an “emperor's new clothes” dynamic. It aligns the interests of government officials with yours in driving a narrative that there was good value generated for the taxpayer from that taxpayer money you got. Also: You now have those millions in a war fund, which you can use as negotiation mass. (In the case of LiMux and Munich, Microsoft relocated their corporate HQ to Munich as a quid pro quo for the City of Munich abandoning the LiMux project, which directly benefitted the City of Munich because it now got to tax Microsoft in a way that it didn't previously get to do). … these kinds of strategies game theoretically dominate any kind of play that's possible through open source.