Re:A billion dollar software tech company is founded every t...
by venus on Monday November 12, 2012 @08:59AM
(#4772830)
> I've visited the site as the googlebot user agent and it is exactly the same as what non-logged in users see
.. except, of course, that the googlebot just reads the HTML. The CSS3 blur only causes problems when you try to read the site visually, via a browser.
> They also aren't doing any tricks to hide the full response in the HTML.
Yes, that's why the googlebot can read it.
I don't know why you're bothering to argue that this isn't cloaking. It most assuredly is.
cloak
verb
conceal, hide, cover, veil, shroud, mask, obscure, cloud
Re:A billion dollar software tech company is founded every t...
by jklio on Monday November 12, 2012 @09:31AM
(#4772933)
Seems they use pngs now but were blurring in the past http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4333151
Re:A billion dollar software tech company is founded every t...
by jwegan on Monday November 12, 2012 @01:29PM
(#4774026)
I guess I should be clearer. The full responses aren't in the HTML at all. The blur effect is just images. Neither you or google see the full responses
Re:A billion dollar software tech company is founded every t...
by newman314 on Monday November 12, 2012 @03:33PM
(#4774627)
Quora may be blurring things for both googlebot and users but it still does not excuse the fact that they are deliberately obscuring content for non-logged in users. So in this respect, they are no better than expertsexchange except maybe a less unfortunate name.
Also FYI, most major search engines have "secret" IPs from which they crawl websites using normal user agents (ex: Chrome, Firefox, etc). They then compare the results to the results from their main crawlers to detect the type of cloaking you referred to.