Re:Visitor Tracking Without Cookies (or How To Abuse HTTP 301s)
by fkdjs on Sunday November 11, 2012 @02:28PM
(#4770329)
If I write a site that logs users in, I keep track of them merely by storing their username in a database as well as a cookie value representing that they are logged in, so do they need to accept terms before logging in?
Re:Visitor Tracking Without Cookies (or How To Abuse HTTP 301s)
by rmc on Monday November 12, 2012 @05:31AM
(#4772264)
There is often "implied consent" for storing local data that is strictly necessary to perform an action that a user has initiated.
Re:Visitor Tracking Without Cookies (or How To Abuse HTTP 301s)
by fkdjs on Monday November 12, 2012 @02:15AM
(#4771916)
Some people use browser fingerprinting for anti-spam techniques, would they need to get the spammer's acceptance before enabling this?
As you can see, these European laws border on absurd.
Re:Visitor Tracking Without Cookies (or How To Abuse HTTP 301s)
by rmc on Monday November 12, 2012 @05:35AM
(#4772273)
the law covers storing data on a user's computer. If you record their personally identifying information (i.e. user agent) on your computers, then that might fall under the decades old data protection directive in EU.
Also if someone does not consent to storing data on their computer and it's necessary to store it to get it to work, then they cannot use your site. The law doesn't require that your site work fine without local data. That would be silly.
The Dutch minister spoke of (freely translated): "Everything that reads or stores your data on your appliance, without permission, without a functional goal other than tracking".
Some techniques like browser fingerprinting ( https://panopticlick.eff.org/ , but also possible with http://modernizr.com/ ) don't store anything on your appliance, but would still fall under the "reading your data from your appliance" part of our law, if used for tracking purposes.
You would need permission to use the "grey" technique from the article. Even if you were to store that data in aggregated form.