Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ...
by Rury on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:56PM
(#47684989)
The term "steelman" arose from people who misunderstand the term "strawman". Such people coined it out of the idea thinking that a strawman was an an attempt to make an opponents argument look weaker than it is, while a "steelman" elevates it to it's highest state before attacking it.
In reality, a steelman is just another strawman. A strawman isn't about making your opponent's argument look weak, it's about making a separate argument that your opponent isn't even arguing about, and attacking that to make it look like you're winning the argument while not actually addressing the opponent's actual argument/position. A steelman does the same. They're both failures in logic - a fallacy of relevance.
In reality, a steelman is just another strawman. A strawman isn't about making your opponent's argument look weak, it's about making a separate argument that your opponent isn't even arguing about, and attacking that to make it look like you're winning the argument while not actually addressing the opponent's actual argument/position. A steelman does the same. They're both failures in logic - a fallacy of relevance.