Re:Show HN: LaughMatch
by thaumaturgy on Saturday November 10, 2012 @06:07PM
(#4768081)
Somewhat ironically, your comment doesn't have anything at all to do with what he actually built -- a really cool new take on personality matching.
There. Fixed it for you.
Perhaps the title has been edited. How do you know this was built in three days?
If I built something decent in three days, I would mention the time frame to boast, not as an excuse. That's also how I imagine most people mean it.
The title was edited.
Not by me. All comments/criticism appreciated. Original title read "Show HN: LaughMatch (MVP built in ~3 days)"
I don't much like HN feature allowing editing title and comments.
Re:Show HN: LaughMatch
by frozenport on Sunday November 11, 2012 @12:14AM
(#4768795)
Another point, days don't translate to effort or even time.
I had to bring up a php site in 3 days. I charged 55 hours in 3 days.
Another time, life was slow and we were benchmarking long runs. I worked less then 40 hours in those 7 days.
Days!=time_spent
Re:Show HN: LaughMatch
by stuffihavemade on Saturday November 10, 2012 @07:21PM
(#4768276)
I think that's wrong philosphy to have. If I've built something (especially a 3 day project when I haven't invested too much time yet), I want all the criticism I can get. Comments like "that seems cool" are just noise. On the ohter hand, someone pointing out a legitimate showstopper can save you 6 months of time working on a dead end idea that could be spent working on something else.
Who's saying anything about what we're supposed to be saying? All I'm saying is "stop saying you built this in 3 days".
If I've gleaned your logic correctly, saying "I built this in three days" attracts the most critique. As such, if you're looking for critique (insensitive or otherwise), that seems like exactly the sort of preface to attach to the title of your submission.
I agree that nobody should be impressed... with all the Rails Rumbles, Django-dashes and StartupWeekend projects I've seen in the past, it takes quite a bit to wow me with a 76 hour project, but I don't know know why that should bother the creator either way.
Edit: Sorry, my eyes are glazed over, and I just realized that's basically exactly what the GP said. Apologies for being repetitive.
That's why he said MVP.
tptacek you rock. Thank you for the comment here.
Get used to people tearing you down. HN is full of people --- most of whom have never built anything --- who tear new products down for sport. But the world is also full of people who will be dismissive in more insidious ways. If you're going to launch products, build up your thick skin now. The industry is full of people who launched less impressive things than this, promoted their work ruthlessly and without neurotic humility, and later went on to run the table on their competitors.