On one hand, management consultants are typically working with the executives of a company, and usually one of those executives will have been a former consultant (the executive boardrooms of companies are filled with them). Not to mention that both consultants and executives usually have the same set of "skills."
On the other hand, one former management consultant I spoke to told me that executives would often hire consultants to tell them what they already knew. The only purpose of bringing the consultants on-board was so that their recommendations would serve as political validation in case they had to explain their decision (i.e. if they failed).
They are hired in order to protect against liability. They are paid money to say what clients want to hear (but in an official "report" and "power point format") and then if shit hits the fan executives can always point to "But look we hired the best of the best, these experts all agreed we should go this, so it is clearly not our fault".
In my experience, this is 100% correct.
At least this mess has been exposed to some degree. There's something of a saying around these kind of projects to the effect of "This project -WILL- succeed".
The subtext being that that no matter what the facts are, the project will be promoted publicly as a success.
It's incredibly disheartening to see an abortive mess transformed into a sparkling success via fake dashboards, paid press and the like.
Mitt Romney’s campaign handed out more than $200,000
in bonuses last month to senior staffers, according
to new disclosure records filed Thursday.
Richard Beeson, Romney’s national political director,
received a $37,500 payment on Aug. 31 in addition to his
salary, according to records filed with the Federal
Election Commission.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/election-2012/wp/2012/09...When I first heard about this, I remarked to a friend "what the hell are they doing giving out bonuses? The bonus should be that your candidate gets elected!"
The Orca thing was obviously an epic fail, but that doesn't mean other people didn't deserve bonuses - maybe their part of the job was just fine.
He probably also had other unknown milestones throughout the campaign in an effort to keep staffers motivated.
http://www.buzzfeed.com/rubycramer/messina-obama-won-on-the-...
http://swampland.time.com/2012/11/07/inside-the-secret-world...
Sounds like they spent quite a bit of time and money on that. Nice article, by the way, though it's obviously a bit of a puff piece.
To build Orca, the Romney campaign turned to Microsoft and an unnamed application consulting firm.
This sounds like a lot of failed IT projects in large corporations -- dreamed up by upper management types who don't know anything about tech, then farmed out to consultants and tech vendors for the actual implementation. The consultants and vendors then either proceed to wander in the weeds expensively due to lack of direction, or actively seize on the client's ignorance and take them for a ride.
The problem is that the people nominally in charge of the project, the upper management types, don't have the experience or expertise to know they're getting taken for a ride until it's too late. So there's no way to hold the contractors accountable, or to get the train back on the rails once it's jumped off.