Re:Supreme Court of Canada Voids Viagra Patent for Insuffici...
by PotatoEngineer on Friday November 09, 2012 @09:36PM
(#4765733)
Ouch, that's nasty. A patent claim that lists a bunch of compounds, of which only one works? No wonder the court struck it down; the filing itself is actively obstructing knowledge.
"Only sildenafil, the subject of Claim 7 and the active compound in Viagra, had been shown to be effective in treating ED at the time of the patent application. Although the patent includes the statement that “one of the especially preferred compounds induces penile erection in impotent males”, the patent application does not disclose that the compound that works is sildenafil, that it is found in Claim 7, or that the remaining compounds had not been found to be effective in treating ED."
The full ruling is here http://www.canlii.org/en/ca/scc/doc/2012/2012scc60/2012scc60...