News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Evil, or why Douglas Crockford is harmful to Free Software by tptacek on Friday November 09, 2012 @08:52AM (#4762750)
It's sad that Crockford wrote a piece of code and gave it away for free in such a way that some people feel they can't use it? How much sadder than all the code every YC company writes and doesn't publish at all?
Re:Evil, or why Douglas Crockford is harmful to Free Software by TorKlingberg on Friday November 09, 2012 @09:20AM (#4762877)
The problem is that the code on json.org is almost free software, and easily mistaken as such.
Re:Evil, or why Douglas Crockford is harmful to Free Software by monochromatic on Friday November 09, 2012 @09:11AM (#4762830)
If others are encouraged to make similar "jokes," yes.
Re:Evil, or why Douglas Crockford is harmful to Free Software by tptacek on Friday November 09, 2012 @09:23AM (#4762885)
So, just to be clear, your take is that the authors of software are not in fact entitled to use whatever license they please?
Re:Evil, or why Douglas Crockford is harmful to Free Software by monochromatic on Friday November 09, 2012 @09:52AM (#4763008)
Obviously they are, and I don't think anyone here is arguing otherwise. Are you focusing on that point because it's the only one that makes this seem acceptable?

The question is whether it is harmful to free software to put unfunny non-jokes like this into licenses. The answer is "yes, it is."

Re:Evil, or why Douglas Crockford is harmful to Free Software by tptacek on Friday November 09, 2012 @12:05PM (#4763665)
No, it isn't. It is harmful for free software projects to blindly incorporate software with incompatible licenses. It is not harmful to write software with incompatible licenses. Most software written is incompatible with Debian. With very few exceptions (for instance, the sole-sourced drivers to popular peripherals), none of it actively harms the project.

Debian is not entitled to Douglas Crockford's work and therefore Crockford cannot harm Debian through incompatibility. Someone else can write a replacement JSON library; it's an intern-level project.

Re:Evil, or why Douglas Crockford is harmful to Free Software by lucisferre on Friday November 09, 2012 @11:15AM (#4763432)
How is anyone making that argument? From what I can see all people are saying is that making an obtuse licencing clause is a bit of an asshole thing to do. I can't see why anyone would disagree with that either.
Re:Evil, or why Douglas Crockford is harmful to Free Software by tptacek on Friday November 09, 2012 @11:24AM (#4763478)
This is one of those situations where 80% of the commenters in the thread will think I am trolling because their sense of entitlement to anything they can read in on a Github page is so powerful that they forget they're talking about the time and effort of an actual human being.

If you feel like you can call someone an "asshole" for writing "use this software for good not evil" in their license, then, and I mean this respectfully but directly, you need to unplug for awhile and interact with actual human beings in the world.

Similarly, if you can write a whole blog post calling Douglas Crockford "childish" and implying that he's not only a hypocrite but hypocritically evil for working at Paypal simply because of something he put in the license of a piece of software he gave away for free, you are a whackjob nutbag and nobody should listen to you.

Here is a clue before 8 different HN'ers explain to me how damaging idiosyncratic license clauses are and why that justified this nutball post: you can write a post about why people shouldn't use a specific free library without calling its author names.

Re:Evil, or why Douglas Crockford is harmful to Free Software by lucisferre on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @05:44PM (#4781063)
Wow, the hypocrisy of using such poorly veiled ad hominem in an attempt call out what you apparently feel is mine, is almost comical. I'd ask you re-read what I said more carefully. It really wasn't nearly as extreme or insulting a statement as you seem to think. Certainly doesn't seem even remotely worth such personal ire.
Re:Evil, or why Douglas Crockford is harmful to Free Software by lucisferre on Friday November 09, 2012 @11:13AM (#4763421)
Ugh, startup code, be glad they don't push all that crap up to Github. I'm more than happy that most sane contributors to open source have a filter on. Not every piece of internal code is needed or wanted be the community.
Re:Evil, or why Douglas Crockford is harmful to Free Software by pbreit on Friday November 09, 2012 @10:33AM (#4763220)
Kind of a lame and unnecessary rip on YC?
Re:Evil, or why Douglas Crockford is harmful to Free Software by tptacek on Friday November 09, 2012 @11:22AM (#4763468)
Sure, if you're hypersensitive or just looking for a fight. I like a lot of YC companies.
Re:Evil, or why Douglas Crockford is harmful to Free Software by pbreit on Sunday November 11, 2012 @11:18AM (#4769788)
I'm neither and my sentiment stands.