News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kasparov and Thiel: Our dangerous illusion of tech progress by guylhem on Thursday November 08, 2012 @07:24PM (#4760641)
This is unfortunately very true.

We don't have a stagnation of tech progress, we keep going forward- but the grow rate seems to be decreasing.

Some people apparently think existing innovation (ex: mindstab comment) suffice to disprove this.

It's not.

Just look at the 40 or 60 to see some real innovation - like antibiotics, nuclear bombs- i.e. paradigm changing innovation in various domains.

What did we got lately? Computers, internet, cellphone, social networking - ok, but it's a bit short, and it's mostly in one domain only.

IMHO, for any self consistent conservative, it's far more worrisome than theoretical weather change, especially because we got used to this fast pace of innovation and growth, and there have built the core of our societies on such assumptions (interest rate for money, population grow for social security, etc) - like, we are expecting technology will improve so that we get new ways problematic (orbital mirrors, tweaking the albedo, ...) to fight climate change if it is indeed man made and

The idea of a deceleration of progress has some merit - to me it's like multiple warnings indicators lighting up, even if I don't know any theory to explain it, except a reduction of the "will to live" in western societies (Nietzsche style)

Re:Kasparov and Thiel: Our dangerous illusion of tech progress by btilly on Thursday November 08, 2012 @10:38PM (#4761133)
Get outside of your niche and look around. Progress is being made in lots of fields. And the rate is not slowing.

For instance 20 years ago mapping a human genome was on the "some day" list and sequencing a single gene was a reasonable PhD thesis. 10 years ago we finished mapping a human genome. Now individuals can get their genome mapped and the price of that is dropping rapidly.

10 years ago, space travel had been stagnant for decades. Now we have SpaceX.

30 years ago scientists rejected the concept of monster waves out of hand, and ships that got destroyed by them were comedy material. (OK, so http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WcU4t6zRAKg really is hilarious.) Today we know that we need to build ships to be 5x as strong.

When I was a kid, superconductivity was an interesting phenomena that needed liquid helium to demonstrate. Today advanced countries (ie not the USA) have floating trains going at hundreds of miles an hour on superconductors. Recently we discovered preliminary evidence of superconductivity at room temperature. If that pans out, how much more will change?

Carbon nanotubes are coming in a big way. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potential_applications_of_carbo... for some of what they will change.

3-d printers are real today, and the technology is improving rapidly.

I could go on, but I think that my point is made. We are making progress at a lot of things that you're not aware of because you're only paying attention to one area of tech. When people look back in 50 years, this will NOT be seen as a period where technology stood still.

Re:Kasparov and Thiel: Our dangerous illusion of tech progress by guylhem on Thursday November 08, 2012 @11:15PM (#4761258)
I never said we are not progressing anymore - just not as fast as before, and we were quite fast (log scale!).

The fact that authors did believe we would have colonies on the Moon or Mars, or flying cars etc should tell you something too - we are not dreaming big anymore, even worse : we discard past dreams.

Look at a GDP per capita curve and see the deep cut. Nothing that big ever before - expect the great depression, where no billion dollar stimulus was applied. Many other factors play of course, but a generally accepted key element for long term grow per capita is technological progress.

Maybe I'm stuck in my niche but I seem to notice something - and share the opinion of other people who seems to spot something too.

Re:Kasparov and Thiel: Our dangerous illusion of tech progress by btilly on Friday November 09, 2012 @02:00AM (#4761743)
Yes, the financial crisis was real. It had a huge impact. Put that many people out of work, and GDP/capita drops.

Doesn't change the fact that there is continuing to be a huge amount of technological progress in a lot of different fields. Not just, as you seem to believe, one narrow area of technology.

Re:Kasparov and Thiel: Our dangerous illusion of tech progress by fudged71 on Thursday November 08, 2012 @10:10PM (#4761071)
I think the biggest improvements to our quality of life will come from 1) energy advancements, 2) transportation (high-speed rail, self-driving cars, electric bikes/skateboards), 3) home advancements (automation, health, adaptive lighting)
Re:Kasparov and Thiel: Our dangerous illusion of tech progress by stcredzero on Thursday November 08, 2012 @09:07PM (#4760905)
Just look at the 40 or 60 to see some real innovation - like antibiotics, nuclear bombs- i.e. paradigm changing innovation in various domains.

Thorium reactors have the potential to be paradigm changing.

Re:Kasparov and Thiel: Our dangerous illusion of tech progress by caretu on Thursday November 08, 2012 @09:25PM (#4760951)
Not really. It would just be an incremental improvement in nuclear fission. A traveling wave reactor would probably be better as it would use existing depleted uranium as fuel, and would produce abundant energy while making uranium stockpiles less of a problem.

Not even fusion would be paradigm changing, unless its cold fusion

Re:Kasparov and Thiel: Our dangerous illusion of tech progress by AlexandrB on Thursday November 08, 2012 @09:52PM (#4761017)
By that logic, nuclear energy was not paradigm changing. Essentially we're still just heating water and using it to move a generator - just like coal or oil power.
Re:Kasparov and Thiel: Our dangerous illusion of tech progress by stcredzero on Thursday November 08, 2012 @10:15PM (#4761079)
> Not really. It would just be an incremental improvement in nuclear fission.

Typical techy shortsightedness. I'm not talking reactor geekery. It would be paradigm changing for society. There's a lot of Thorium out there in the world, and nuclear power would be disconnected from proliferation risk.

> Not even fusion would be paradigm changing, unless its cold fusion

Again, typical techy shortsightedness.