News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:C++26 is done ISO C++ standards meeting, Trip Report by aw1621107 on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:16PM (#47582003)
> What nasal demons?

Those that result from the pre-C++26 behavior where use of an indeterminate value is UB.

> But there’s lots of room between deterministic values and UB.

That's a fair point. I do think I made a mistake in how I represented the authors' decision, as it seems the authors intentionally wanted the predictability of fixed values (italics added):

> Reading an uninitialized value is never intended and a definitive sign that the code is not written correctly and needs to be fixed. At the same time, we do give this code well-defined behaviour, and if the situation has not been diagnosed, we want the program to be stable and predictable. This is what we call erroneous behaviour.

> And I think the word “indeterminate” should have been reserved for that sort of behavior.

Perhaps, but that'd be a departure from how the word has been/is used in the standard so there would probably be some resistance against redefining it.

There are no comments on this comment yet.