Re:Was Intrade being manipulated over the last month?
by bcoates on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:58AM
(#4756645)
One thing you have to watch out for on Intrade-Betfair arbitrage is the not insignificant risk of not doing the trades you think you're doing. I know Intrade has rules that various events will cause trades to be stopped and completed trades will be undone. Betfair might as well, but the two markets don't have any synchronization on when or why.
Since you'll constantly have many times what you expect to gain in a day at risk on the markets, a single rollback event could put you very deep in the red.
Re:Was Intrade being manipulated over the last month?
by javert on Wednesday November 07, 2012 @11:44PM
(#4756524)
aren't markets supposed to be efficient
To a certain extent. Largely because of people doing arbitrage. So, if all arbitrageurs called it quits because they thought markets are automatically efficient, well, they wouldn't be.
Did you make much money?
Re:Was Intrade being manipulated over the last month?
by zecho on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:01AM
(#4756555)
There's an economics joke as old as the hills:
An economist and a non-economist are walking down the street when the non-economist notices something on the ground and says, "hey there's a $10 bill!" The economist replies, "Impossible. If there was a $10 bill on the ground, someone would have picked it up already."
Re:Was Intrade being manipulated over the last month?
by pja on Thursday November 08, 2012 @05:49AM
(#4757256)
On my summer holiday this year I was walking along Hadrian's Wall & looked down to see a £5 note being blown along the path by the wind. Picked it up & was instantly reminded of this joke :)
Re:Was Intrade being manipulated over the last month?
by lincolnq on Thursday November 08, 2012 @12:36AM
(#4756616)
I had a friend who made $10,000 (off a $200k bankroll) in 2008 doing this exact form of arbitrage...
Re:Was Intrade being manipulated over the last month?
by maxerickson on Thursday November 08, 2012 @08:38AM
(#4757721)
I think a greater number of U.S. participants on Intrade is one of the better explanations.
I wouldn't be surprised if personal biases play a bigger factor than the media.
Our only explanation was that betfair (our other side) was mostly European while Intrade was mostly American so it is possible that lots of Intrade betters were buying into the media's attempt to try to make the race a lot closer than it was while the Europeans were not so biased. I don't know but it is a simpler explanation than someone purposely losing money because they think influencing a prediction market would affect the actual outcome?