That's just a nice side effect of a sufficiently liquid market.
But it does make it less useful for third party observers :)
If speculators respond to incentives and take their money, markets will be pushed back to normal. I think Robin Hanson even has a paper or two proving this is the equilibrium strategy. As the article indicates, he even put his money where his mouth is.
______________
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corn_Laws.
[2] In particular, bounded rationality and opportunism.
edits: clarity
Surely the liberal interventionist position requires an assumption of irrational behaviour from market participants - that's the only way e.g. regulation to prevent bubbles would make sense.
But there is no contradiction of any sort between (1,2) and (3).
Which is maybe just as well, because in fact (3) is true.
(It seems to me that (1) is an interesting but irrelevant historical point, and (2) is merely irrelevant smoke-blowing, whose best explanation is that you're more partisan than you let on here. But I could be wrong.)
The main point of this thread -- about the price of X being one thing or another -- does not (appear to) need a critique of rationality to explain, however. In that regards, it is superflous. Whether this price is 'belief' or 'manipulation' (ie, strategy), the market would be needing to evidence preferences <accurately> for the prefernces to be revealed. Manipulation in this sense is a variation of strategic preferencing.[2] Again, this is a notion more consistent with <hyper rationality> than its opposite. Whether or not Market A and Market B have the same price is also simply explained by lack of common market participants. A textbook 'inefficiency' may result, but again this is not anywhere near a critique of rationality, proper.
Lastly, thinking orthogonally to the orthodoxy is not 'conservative' its actually 'liberal' but this requires omission of capital letters [3] and some sense of history to understand. Which is the larger point about rhetoric. And closer to my personal worldview.
_________
[1] ie, Krugman vs http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/13/business/economy/13nobel.h...
[2] preferences are </meta> to orthdox economics, as its practised by keynesian-style interventionists and neo-liberals (er, Conservatives) alike.
[3] Liberal is now a modern brand, not a reference point of clear thinking.
I remember observing a similar thing around the betting on the supreme court healthcare decision. The odds were 3-4 points more against the legislation on intrade than they were on other sites. The comments were overwhelmingly partisan and conservative. "The Supreme Court will find this unconstitutional because Obama is a socialist."
The idea behind prediction markets is that people will only bet when they know something that the rest of us don't. But we shouldn't underestimate the human ability to convince ourselves that everyone else feels as strongly about an issue as we do.